Manson v. Caron

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF CONNECTICUT James Manson, Plaintiff, Civil No. 3:24-cv-00876-MPS v. Caron et al, Defendants. June 25, 2024 RECOMMENDED RULING ON PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS 1. Introduction The plaintiff, James Manson, is an inmate at the Enfield Correctional Institution in Enfield, Connecticut. He has sued several prison officials for violating his civil rights (Compl., ECF No. 1), and he also applied for leave to proceed in forma pauperis, or “IFP.” (ECF No. 2.) In other words, he asked for permission to begin his suit without pre-paying $405.00 in filing and administrative fees. The Clerk of the Court assigned Mr. Manson’s case to United States District Judge Michael P. Shea. In the District of Connecticut, however, motions for leave to proceed IFP are reviewed in the first instance by a United States Magistrate Judge. See United States District Court for the District of Connecticut, Guide for Self-Represented Litigants, at 6 (“[T]he motion to proceed in forma pauperis . . . will be reviewed by a Magistrate Judge.”). When the motion deserves to be granted, the Magistrate Judge will typically be the one to grant it. See, e.g., Ambrose v. Guadaramma, No. 3:24-cv-926 (VAB) (TOF), 2024 WL 2836228 , at *2 (D. Conn. May 31, 2024). But when the IFP motion deserves to be denied, the Magistrate Judge will ordinarily only recommend denial to the District Judge, rather than deny it himself. This is because Magistrate Judges are not generally authorized to dismiss cases, and denying an IFP motion can sometimes be “the functional equivalent of an involuntary dismissal[.]” Woods v. Dahlberg, 894 F.2d 187 (6th Cir. 1990). The undersigned Magistrate Judge has reviewed Mr. Manson’s application and supporting materials. For the reasons that follow, he recommends that Judge Shea deny the motion for leave to proceed IFP. 2. Governing Legal Principles A federal law allows inmates to commence civil actions without pre-paying the filing fee when, among other requirements, they submit affidavits showing that they are “unable to pay.” 28 U.S.C. § 1915 . The Supreme Court has explained that an IFP affidavit “sufficient[ly]” demonstrates an inability to pay when it shows that the applicant “cannot because of his poverty pay or give security for the costs and still be able to provide himself and [his] dependents with the necessities of life.” Adkins v. E.I. DuPont de Nemours & Co., 335 U.S. 331, 339 (1948). While the applicant does not need to prove absolute destitution, Potnick v. E. State Hosp., 701 F.2d 243, 244 (2d Cir. 1983), he does need to show that pre-paying the fee would “constitute a serious hardship.” Fiebelkorn v. U.S., 77 Fed. Cl. 59, 62 (2007). When a prisoner’s inmate trust account balance is lower than the filing fee, courts often grant leave to proceed IFP. In Simmons v. Torres, for example, an inmate filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus, which ordinarily requires a $5.00 filing fee. No. 3:07-cv-1409 (VLB), 2007 WL 3171356 , at *1 (D. Conn. Oct. 26, 2007). Because he “provided a copy of his inmate account statement reflecting a spendable balance of $0.43,” Judge Bryant granted his motion to proceed IFP. Id. Yet courts typically deny IFP motions when the inmate’s low trust account balance is a result of his own voluntary spending decisions. As Judge Shea has previously explained, when “considering a prisoner’s affidavit of indigence, the district court may inquire whether, if a prisoner has no cash credit at the moment of filing, he had disabled himself by a recent drawing on his account and if so, for what purposes.” Hinton v. Pearson, No. 3:21-cv-863 (MPS), 2021 WL 3036921 , at *2 (D. Conn. July 19, 2021) (quoting Miller v. Brown, No. CV 112-166, 2013 WL 1346826 , at *2 (S.D. Ga. Feb. 21, 2013)) (quotation marks omitted). In Hinton, the plaintiff had only $132.91 in his trust account at the time he filed his suit. Id. at *1. But his account statement revealed that he had received over $3,500.00 in the preceding six months, money that he “chose to spend . . . in the commissary or send . . . out of the facility.” Id. at *2. Because “[t]he plaintiff had sufficient funds to pay the filing fee . . . but chose to spend those funds on other things to render himself eligible for [IFP] status,” the Court denied his IFP motion. Id.; see also Clark v. Pappoosha, No. 3:21-cv-1690 (CSH), 2022 WL 960296 , at *2 (D. Conn. Mar. 30, 2022) (denying IFP motion in part because inmate “received a total of $1,645.00 in deposits during a six-month period prior to filing [his] action,” yet “made numerous personal withdrawals”); Brown v. Ruiz, No. 3:20-cv-1202 (KAD), 2020 WL 6395480 , at *1 (D. Conn. Nov. 2, 2020) (denying IFP motion because inmate “had deposits exceeding $3,850.00 in the seven months prior to filing [his] action,” but “made purchases at the commissary and regularly sent money out of the facility”). Before denying an IFP motion on account of an inmate’s spending, however, courts must consider whether the inmate’s expenditures were necessary or optional. As noted above, the Supreme Court has held that a litigant is entitled to proceed IFP if he shows that he cannot simultaneously pay the filing fee and afford “the necessities of life.” Adkins, 335 U.S. at 339 . And while the Second Circuit has observed that “what constitutes the ‘necessities of life’ . . . is obviously different for prisoners, most of whose necessities are paid for by the jurisdiction that incarcerates them[,]” In re Epps, 888 F.2d 964, 967 (2d Cir. 1989), it has also observed that inmates sometimes have “financial obligations” such as “medical debts, court fees, student loans[,]” and family support orders. Rosa v. Doe, 86 F.4th 1001, 1009 (2d Cir. 2023). These obligations “warrant consideration” in the IFP analysis, and they can support IFP status even when the inmate’s account balance exceeds the filing fee by a meaningful amount. Id. The plaintiff in Rosa, for example, claimed to “support[] his mother and son with monthly payments totaling $86.66,” and he was therefore entitled to IFP status even though his account balance exceeded the filing fee by $174.98. Id. at 1005-06, 1009-10 . To help prisoners demonstrate the necessity of their expenses, the District of Connecticut has prepared a standard IFP application form. (ECF No. 2.) The form prompts the applicant to disclose “[h]ow much money” he “contribute[s] each month to the support of family members or other individuals,” and it gives him space to state the name of the person he supports and his relationship to him or her. (Id. at 3.) The form also prompts the applicant to state the amount he “spend[s] each month on necessities of life that are not provided for [him] by the Department of Correction,” and it gives him space to identify the items he purchases and the amounts he spends on each one. (Id.) Finally, the form invites him to attach additional pages if he needs more space in which to explain his necessary expenses. (Id.) A copy of the form is attached as Exhibit A. 3. Application to Mr. Manson’s Case In this case, Mr. Manson filled out the form, and he provided a certified copy of his inmate trust account statement as required by 28 U.S.C. § 1915 . The last entry on the trust account statement reflects a balance of $213.51, which is $191.49 less than the $405.00 filing fee. (ECF No. 3.) But the statement also reflects that he spent $2,935.17 in the preceding six months. (ECF No. 3.) Thus, the principal question presented by his IFP motion is whether he has sufficiently shown those expenses to have been necessary. He has not. To begin with, Mr. Manson stated in his IFP application form that he does not contribute to the financial support of any family member or other individual. (ECF No. 2, at 3.) Moreover, he disclosed no student loans, medical debts, restitution obligations, or any of the other obligations referenced by the Second Circuit in Rosa. Rather, Mr. Manson claims to spend $1,016.281 each month on himself - $371.42 for “food and hygiene”; $639.81 on “food, clothing, [and] cosmetics”; and $5.05 on cologne. (Id.) He does not explain why “cosmetics” and “cologne” qualify as “necessities of life,” and accordingly his claim boils down to this: even though the Department of Correction (“DOC”) feeds and clothes him, he must necessarily spend over $1,000.00 a month – or over $12,000.00 per year – on other food and clothing or on personal hygiene items. This claim cannot be accepted. The court keeps itself informed on the prices that the DOC charges for food, toiletries and other personal care items, and this level of spending cannot possibly be “necessary.” According to the DOC’s commissary price list, which is attached as Exhibit B, the commissary charge for a Snickers bar is $1.37; hair gel costs $2.41; and a tube of toothpaste costs $1.59. Thus, the amount that Mr. Manson claims to spend would buy 200 Snickers bars, 200 bottles of hair gel, and 150 tubes of toothpaste – every month, and on top of the resources the Department provides him for free. And even if one uses the $489.20 figure suggested by the trust account statement – rather than the $1,016.28 figure that Mr. Manson provided under penalty of perjury – he could still buy a box of cereal ($4.98), a can of beef stew ($2.08), a bag of Doritos ($2.20), a candy bar ($1.37), a bottle of shampoo ($1.99), and a package of AAA batteries ($2.73) 1 The trust account statement does not confirm these claims. As noted above, the statement shows expenses of $2,935.17 from November 2023 to April 2024, a rate of $489.20 per month. every single day of his incarceration, and still have more than $30.00 left over each month for postage, movie and music downloads, and the like. Considering the prices charged by the DOC for food, toiletries, and personal care items, neither $489.20 nor $1,016.28 can be regarded as a “necessary” level of spending. “[A]ll litigants must make decisions about how to spend their money when they are contemplating litigation.” Brown, 2020 WL 6395480 , at *1. “If the inmate thinks a more worthwhile use of his funds would be to buy” non-essential items than to pay a filing fee, “he has demonstrated an implied evaluation of the suit that the district court is entitled to honor.” Id. (quoting Lumbert v. Ill. Dep’t of Corr., 827 F.2d 257, 260 (7th Cir. 1987)). While Mr. Manson does not currently have the $405.00 filing fee in his account, this is the result of his own voluntary spending decisions. Here, as in Hinton, “[t]he plaintiff had sufficient funds to pay the filing fee . . . but chose to spend those funds on other things[.]” 2021 WL 3036921 , at *2. “[T]his is not the proper use of the in forma pauperis statute.” Id. The Court notes that Mr. Manson’s complaint arises out of a strip search that occurred on March 8, 2024. (Compl., ECF No. 1, at 3.) It therefore acknowledges that the sums he spent before that date could not have been for the calculated purpose of rendering himself eligible for IFP status, because he did not yet know that he might be filing this suit. See Sanders v. Martin, No. 3:24-cv-1005, slip op. at 3-4 (D. Conn. June 24, 2024) (observing that, although 28 U.S.C. § 1915 directs district courts to consider an inmate’s expenses for the six months preceding his suit, the “most relevant” period is the period when he was “contemplating litigation”). But even after the strip search, Mr. Manson kept spending at levels that cannot be regarded as “necessary.” (See ECF No. 3) (trust account statement reflecting nearly $850.00 in commissary and other purchases between March 8, 2024 and April 30, 2024). Indeed, on March 15, 2024 – just a week after the strip search – he spent $50.00 on “JPay Media” entertainment downloads. (Id. at 3.) Finally, the Court notes another, independent reason for recommending dismissal of Mr. Manson’s IFP motion. In considering whether a litigant is entitled to IFP status, courts consider not only the litigant’s own resources, but also “the resources that the applicant has or can get from those who ordinarily provide [him] with the necessities of life, such as from a spouse, parent, adult sibling or other next friend.” Fridman v. City of N.Y., 195 F. Supp. 2d 534, 537 (S.D.N.Y 2002) (quotation marks and citation omitted). In this case, even if the Court were to imagine that Mr. Manson genuinely spends hundreds and hundreds of dollars a month on “necessities” not provided for him by the DOC, those necessities are being supplied by a family member or friend. The trust account discloses that, in addition to the $40.00 that he earns each month as a prison barber, Mr. Manson receives an average of $412.95 in outside deposits. (ECF No. 3) (reflecting $2,477.70 in deposits other than prison pay between November 2023 and April 2024). For the foregoing reasons, I recommend that Judge Shea deny the plaintiff’s motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis. The plaintiff is respectfully advised that if Judge Shea accepts my recommendation, he will have to pay the $405.00 filing fee or his lawsuit will likely be dismissed. See, e.g., Richardson v. Napoli, No. 9:09-CV-1440 (TJM) (DEP), 2010 WL 1235383 (N.D.N.Y. Mar. 30, 2010) (dismissing case where plaintiff neither demonstrated his entitlement to proceed in forma pauperis nor paid the filing fee). This is a recommended ruling by a magistrate judge. Fed. R. Civ. P. 72(b)(1); D. Conn. L. Civ. R. 72.1(C). If the plaintiff wishes to object to my recommendation, he must file that objection with the Clerk of the Court by July 15, 2024. See Fed. R. Civ. P. 72(b)(2) (objections to magistrate judge recommendations to be filed within fourteen days); D. Conn. L. Civ. R. 72.2(a) (allowing five additional days for persons who receive the recommendation from the Clerk of the Court via mail); Fed. R. Civ. P. 6(a)(2)(C) (stating that, when a filing period “would end on a Saturday, Sunday, or legal holiday, the period continues to run until . . . the next day that is not a Saturday, Sunday, or legal holiday”). If he fails to file a timely objection, his failure “operates as a waiver of any further judicial review[.]” Small v. Sec’y of Health & Human Servs., 892 F.2d 15, 16 (2d Cir. 1989). In particular, failure to file a timely objection operates as a waiver of the right to seek appellate review in the Court of Appeals. Id.; see also 28 U.S.C. § 636 (b)(1); Fed. R. Civ. P. 72; Fed. R. Civ. P. 6; see also Impala v. U.S. Dep’t of Justice, 670 F. App’x 32 (2d Cir. 2016) (summary order). /s/ Thomas O. Farrish Hon. Thomas O. Farrish United States Magistrate Judge EXHIBIT A UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF CONNECTICUT PRISONER'S APPLICATION TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS IN A CIVIL RIGHTS ACTION ATTACH THIS FORM TO YOUR COMPLAINT : PRISONER [Your name] : NO: cv ( ) Plaintiff, : [Leave blank for Clerk] : vs. : : : : : [People you are suing] : Defendant(s): I, , [your name] state that, because of my poverty, I am unable to pay the filing fee for the above-captioned lawsuit at the time that I file my complaint. I therefore request permission to file my complaint without pre-payment of the filing fee, and to proceed in forma pauperis (as a poor person). I understand that I cannot file for free. I realize that even if the Court allows me to proceed in forma pauperis, I will have to pay the full filing fee of $350 through installments deducted from my inmate trust fund. I also understand that the Department of Correction Inmate Trust Fund will continue to deduct money from my inmate trust fund to pay the filing fee to the Court, even if my lawsuit is dismissed. I also understand that I must support my claim of poverty by truthfully answering all of the following questions and by obtaining a signed certification of the balance of my inmate trust fund from the DOC Inmate Trust Fund or my prison counselor. I realize that I may be prosecuted for perjury if I lie on this application, and that perjury is punishable by imprisonment for up to five years and/or a fine of $250,000 ( 18 U.S.C. §§ 1621 , 3571). WARNING: You MUST complete EVERY section, or your application may be denied. Answer every question truthfully and accurately. If the true and accurate answer to a question is “zero” or “not applicable,” you must write that – do not leave the question blank. 1. Full Name: ________________________________________________________ 2. Inmate Number: ____________________________________________________ 3. Correctional Institution: ______________________________________________ 4. Are you currently employed? (Yes or No): ________________________________ 5. If you are currently employed, state your job title and the amount you get paid each month: Job: _____________________________________________________________ Monthly wages: $ __________________________________________________ 6. Within the past twelve (12) months, how much money have you received from the following sources? If none, write “zero.” a. Employment: Type ________________________________ $ _____________ b. Rent someone paid you: $ _________________________________________ c. Interest on savings: $ _____________________________________________ d. Dividends on investments: $ ________________________________________ e. Pensions, annuities, or life insurance: $ _______________________________ f. Gifts or inheritances: $ ____________________________________________ g. Disability payments: $ ____________________________________________ h. Other sources: Type ______________________________ $ _____________ 7. How much money do you have in cash, or in checking or savings accounts, including your inmate trust account? If none, write “zero.” $ _______________ 8. What is the total value of property you own, excluding ordinary household furnishings and clothing, but including automobiles, real estate, stocks, bonds, and notes? If none, write “zero.” $ _______________ 9. How much money do you contribute each month to the support of family members or other individuals? Provide the name of each person you support and the relationship between you (e.g., husband, wife, domestic partner, child, or grandparent). If you need more space, attach an additional page. a. Name & Relationship: _________________________ $ ________________ b. Name & Relationship: _________________________ $ ________________ c. Name & Relationship: _________________________ $ ________________ 10. How much money do you spend each month on necessities of life that are not provided for you by the Department of Correction? State the item and amount, and if you need more space, attach an additional page. a. Item: ______________________________________ $ ________________ b. Item: ______________________________________ $ ________________ c. Item: ______________________________________ $ ________________ DECLARATION UNDER PENALTY OF PERJURY WARNING: You MUST sign this section or your application for IFP status will be denied. I, , the applicant, declare under penalty of perjury that the information I have provided in this application is true and correct. Signed: ________________________________________________________________ Dated: _________________________________________________________________ WARNING: You have not finished. You MUST complete the next section. PRISONER AUTHORIZATION WARNING: You MUST complete and sign this section and then show this page to the Inmate Trust Fund Department or your prison counselor so that they can sign the next section. Your name: _____________________________________________________________ Your inmate number: ______________________________________________________ DOC facility where you are detained: _________________________________________ Case Number [leave blank for Clerk]: Filing Date [leave blank for Clerk]: I, , the applicant, understand that even if my request for In Forma Pauperis status is granted, Congress has said that I must pay the full filing fee of $350, which will be deducted in installments from my inmate trust fund. I further understand that the deductions from my inmate trust fund will continue until the full fee is paid, even if my case is dismissed before then. I authorize the Department of Correction Inmate Trust Fund to: (1) certify on the next page of this application the current and average balance over the last six months of my inmate trust fund; (2) send the Court copies of my trust fund statement for the past six months; (3) obtain funds to cover the $350 filing fee by deducting installment payments from my inmate trust fund based on the average of deposits to or balance in my inmate trust fund, in accordance with 28 U.S.C. Section 1915 ; (4) send the $350 payment for the filing fee to the Court. Signed: ___________________________________________ [Your signature] Date: _____________________________________________ [Today’s date] WARNING: You have not finished. You MUST show this page to the Inmate Trust Fund Department or your prison counselor so that they can sign the next section. Do NOT send this application to the Court without the signature of the Inmate Trust Fund Department or your prison counselor on the next page. [4] Revised 12/15/2023 CERTIFICATION OF INMATE ACCOUNT BALANCE WARNING: You MUST show this application to the Inmate Trust Fund Department or your prison counselor so that they can read page 4 and sign this section. Your name: _____________________________________________________________ Your inmate number: _____________________________________________________ DOC facility where you are detained: _________________________________________ I, ______________________________, counselor/employee of the Connecticut Department of Correction Inmate Trust Fund, certify that the applicant named herein has the sum of $ _____________ on account. I further certify that, according to the records of the institution, the applicant’s average balance for the past six months was $ ________________ and the average monthly deposits during the same period were $ ________________. A certified copy of the applicant’s trust fund statement for the last six (6) months is attached. Signed: ________________________________________________________________ (Inmate Trust Fund Officer or Prison Counselor) Name & Rank: ___________________________________________________________ Date: __________________________________________________________________ [5] Revised 12/15/2023 CHECKLIST FOR IFP APPLICATION NOTE: Before you send this application to the Court, you MUST: _________ Sign the declaration under penalty of perjury on p. 3. _________ Sign the Prisoner Authorization on p. 4. _________ Show the application to the Inmate Trust Fund Department or your prison counselor and have them sign p. 5. _________ Answer every question truthfully and accurately. _________ Attach the trust fund statement for the last six (6) months (ledger sheet). [6] Revised 12/15/2023 EXHIBIT B @feTal-1e-] Mace) □□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□□ elec (=\mi me) cin) Level 1 = $50, Level 2 = $55, Level 3 = $60 (items marked LOC only) INMATE NUMBER lam a that the total cost -- al ware thal □□ cos' Facillty Housing Unit Bed Location MUST BE FILLED IN of these items □□ be ees asi deducted from my account. State sales tax is not included Print Name 6 ds in the prices listed below and will be added where SO) applicable. Taxable items at a Sign Here DOODD sate of 6.35% are marked with When Ordering X “)@Q@]2|]D—) a double-asterisk (**). Taxable items at a rate of 7.35% are NO REFUNDS - NO TRADES >QDHDHD > marked with a triple-asterisk INSTRUCTIONS DOOOO®, err re are □□□ □□□□□□□□□□ for typographical errors. This Use black pen or pencil and fill in the bubbles completely. CORRECT AR a a > order is subject to posted Any stray marks may cause your order to be processed e aOOoOO®D Commissary rules. Prices are incorrectly. subject to change without PO) notice. | est a OS i leeds | | i ee EY a □□□ □□ STATIONERY 354 | Mennen Speed Stick’ -Male LOC} 3.20 109 | Stamped Envelope LOCID © @ @ @] 0.54 349 | Power up Deodorant’ Loc] 3,34 112 | Postcard LOC|D ® @ d Gh) 0.87 3422 | Suave Antiperspirant** LOCI®D @ 2.00 113 | Manila Envelope** LOCI®D © @ @® BW} 0.15 355 | Dial Rell-On** LOC |G @ 1.36 107 | International Postage Envelope LOCID @ @ @ Gj 1.50 [AIR 106 | Writing Pad** LOCID @ @@ @®) 1.13 364 | Softee 3-in-1 Conditioning Shampoo"" = LOC;|G@) Go 4.37 110 | Ink Pen** LOC|I®D @ 0.19 365 || Softee 3-in-1 Daily Condiligiyar** LOCI @ 4.37 114-111] Pencil**(0.12) Eraser** (0.50) Be Oe 1267, 2208] VO5 Shampoo (1.73)**, VO5 Conditioner (188) LOCI @ □□ 104,101] Spanish Dictionary**(1.80) English Dictionary"*(3.32) LOC|#) 362 | Elementz Shamnoo™ LOCID @ 1.99 108 | Address Book** Loc} 0.77 363 | Elementz Gonditiones LOCID @ 2.27 102 | Photo Album** 2.21 i ‘\ — 103 | Colored Pencils** O® 2.20) 3740 landhyf Bhamkoo™ LOC}I® @ 3.07 105 | Sketch Pad/Typing Paper** DOO@®@DP\| Lod | Foz | Sryling Gaps D@®@ 2.41 125 | Composition Book™" LOC|D @ @ AV 1.54) \ 979) Bergamdt Gonditioner™ LOCI@ @ 1.79 115 | Youth Birthday Card** LOCID @D®@ +41 Pra Gilo Gel\Pomadde"* LOCID @ 2.18 | 116 | Female Birthday Card** LOCIGD OD H] Ney) | 'GAl | Protein 2o\Hyir Gake D@® 3.59 i 123 | Male Birthday Card** __LOGID Gach G@ Gp) 1.64 ‘Bt □□□ Woistiyiding Hair Oil" De® 4.70 + 117 | Friendship Card** a LONG ay ae LAN} js7a\see| cok Aer _ (2 nive Pick** (0.62) ce 1 118 | Love You Card** \ Los CD) GAD eC 1 64) \ |381 Afra Cetin Bien Pocket Comb**(0 65) LOCK 119 | Anniversary Card** \ \ \LOC i cH @D @j\ 1.61}, \ les 265) Fien Gro"(6 32) Sotoo Conditioner Coconut OHM? 16) LOew@me 120 | Holiday Card** \ VLOG 1B) GD OVD) GBy) 1.64) [a73yo) pos pu aunens*w01) il nition, Built 18.07) iB) □ 121 | Get Well Card** \ LOCIM\@ □□ @®) sei] [SKIN CARE 122 | Sympathy Card** \ OC|D SD QS Dy\ 1.64 392 | Dial Advanced Therapy Lotion™* LOC|@ 3.82 126 | Thank you Gard** \ OC/@D (Os) 1.61 831 | Tone Lotion” LOC] 3.16 MEDICAI \ er 1039 | Lubriderm Lotion** LOCcia@D 4.01 Fish Oil Vitamin -S (3.75) Sun Block" (359) = LOC|GE @) 50,2600] Men’s Body Wash" -Male (3 37), Irish Spring § in 1 Body Wash** (7 80) LOC |G a Multi Vitamin -S(3.55) Vitamin C-S(3.35) “~ LOCI@ @® 395 | Stick, Cocoa Butter** LOCIKD @ □□□□ Rolaids 3 Roll pk: -K (2.01), Melatonin 3mg (5:20) LOC|G® GR Gp Gb 398 | Vaseline Skin Care Lotion** LOC}@ 4.1€ 207,208} Antacid Liquid (3.55) Pepcid AC, 6ct (7.23) LOC)Gm 399 | Vitamin E Gel LOC}? 4.74 | axative Powder (11,67) Immodium AD 12ct, (10,48) LOC|G 393 | Noxzema** Loc|a@ 1.76 |buprofen 24 ct (2. 10) Acetaminophen 24ct,(1 92) Loca@QDd @es 394 | Baby Powder** Loc} 1.73 Artificial Tears Drops (1.93) Nasal Spray (1 47) Loc] @ 396 | Cotton Swabs** @ 1,02 Allergy Tabs (1.28) Tussin Cough Syrup (2.03) Loc|@®> @ MISCELLANEOUS Foot Cream (1,37) Quinsana Foot Powder (6 83) LOC |q@~ @ 400 | Bath Towel™ LOC/G@o. 7.08 240-275] Benzoyl Peroxide (1,30) Bacitracin Ointment (1.88) LOC|GE 408 | Cotton Face Cloth** LOC|G @ 0.97 2 Hydrocortisone Cream (1.47) Hemorhoidal Qintment (3 50) LOC|® 409 | Toilet Paper** LOC|GCD @ 0,68 Muscle Rub (2.18) Shoe Insoles (2.03) LOC} 415 | Coffee Cup** cb 1.66 Blistex Med, Lip Ointment (2.21) Vaseline Lip Therapy (1.54) LOC |g @® @ 411 | Plastic Cup & Lid** De® 0.4 81.00 | Nasal Strips LOC|@> 11,04 405 | Plastic Bowl & Lid** De® □□□□ |_SOAP(LIMIF2TOTAL) C“‘‘CCC*dSC 4410 | Plastic Spork-Spoon Combo** DOO@O® 0.46 293,868] Oatmeal Soap**(1.43) Ambi Soap**(2.71) LOC|is @. Ga 902.903] Y-Adapter*(3.74) Headphone Extension**(4.05) om dé cH Dove Soap** (1,82) Coast Soap Bar**(0.98) LOCI@ @ dO Ge) 407 | Soap Dish** i @ 0.56 1047 | Next 1 Moisturizing Bar** LOCI®: @ 1,08} — |aesare0] Fingernail Clipper** Emery Boards** GE) □□ 0.66 1048 | Cocoa Butter Bar** LOC} @ 1.10 503 | Handkerchief** @ 0.7% 1049 | Sports Bar, Antibacterial"* LOc]a @ 1d 404 | Mirror** cD 2.15 DENTAL L416 | Laundry Powder Clear Bag** LOoc|cD 1.17 335 | Fixodert Denture Adhesive** LOCI@ @ 9.10} | 427,73 | Dominoes**(2.94) Uno Cards**(8.04) BD □□ 371 | Staydent Denture Adhesive** LOC|I@D @ 2.73 425 | Chess Set** cD 4.1 Sensodyne Toothpaste”*(7 67) Efferdent Cleaner**(7.88) LOG| @& @ & 426 | Checker Set** @D □□□ Close Up toothpaste**{2,21) Aim Tartar Control Toothpaste**(1 90) LOC @ @® @® @ 426420\) Pinochle Cards**(1.48) Poker Cards**(0.72) D @ a & 319 | Whitening Colgate Toothpaste** LOC|@D@ 3,54 906 | Mono/Stereo Adapter** Logie 2.18 331 | Ultra Brite Toothpaste** LOCID @ 1,59 500 | Shower Shoes** S) @D DM □□ □□□ 2.55 327 | Tek Excel Toothbrush, Soft** LOC|® 0.58] boomenog AA Beattenes"'(2.98) AAA Batteries (2.75)'" LOC |@ □ 330 | Toothbrush Holder** LOC|I@ @ 0.37 FEMALE ONL’ 326 | Mouthwash** LOC|@D @ 1.24 821 | Tampons** LOOIGY CD) Qa) yy 5.4: 8102 | Panil Liner** LOCID □□□□□□□ 2.4 | Dental Floss Sticks** iD 1.12 822 | Maxi Pads** LOCID @ □ □ □□ 2:6: SHA’ —__i 813 | Mascara** a @ 1,37 358 | Razor Card"* -Male LOCI 41.0 814 | Eye/Brow Pencils** M@® 1.0 i 348 | Pro-Tection Shave Cream** LOCcI@a @ 2.08 384 | Gel Curl Activator** @D □□ 351 | Magic Shave** -Male LOCID @ 3.51 817 | Hair Relaxer** cD 7.4 2690 | Abe Choayea*’? Adal toereney J Ary 46 | SGhaarmninn fren Arnnlea** Torn □□□ (aged □□□ Sh ahs ae (oes a Waa) Tea □ □□□ □□□ oe 815 | Vent Brush" ® 0.78 {063 | Yellowfin Tuna Steak in Spicy Thai Chili- K,H,G QD De 2.74 819 | Styling Brush** @ 1,34) 0131 Kosher Dill Pickles- K,G,S D@OO®@® □□ □□□□□ 820 | Shower Cap** D® 0.29) 1038 | Cheesy Refried Beans -K, H DOOD □□□□ 1.17 Large Foam Rollers**(2.47) Nair Hair Remover"*(5 85) Qo 578 | Black Beans -G DOQ®D 1.42 829 | Black & White Bleaching Cream** D@® 7.00) 2216 | Sweet Corn -H, S D®@®®D □ 1,17) 800 | Lady Speed Stick** LOCI @ 1.93) | 2068 | Pasta Shells D)O@@ 0.55 | Sure Deodorant** LOC|ID @ 2.85) 609 | Ramen Chicken, Less Sodium -S [Note: |) @® @ @ Gj □□□□□□ 397_| Coconut | inl Hai a Bidy Wastits LOC 34 610 | Ramen Beef, Less Sodium -S Limit 24 © @ @ □□ □□□□□ may only order itemp on the welte ti lint here. Any iter NOT on tive write tn Tet will be crwdited, 0602 | Ramen Spicy Vegetable, Less Sodium-S Soups |@)@® @ @ Gj 0.52 the item number exactly in the top spaces and darken the matching numbers below. 0605 | Ramen Chili, Less Sodium -S Tota] (OOOQOSB| 052 2622 | Chipotle Bowl with Black Beans DOO@O@OA 540 Lif | | 70__| Instant Lunch, Cup of Soup DOD ® @ 6:69) ANDY □ OOD MVODD WOe: 672 | S.F. Breath Savers*** -S OD®D @® □□□□□ DOOD WOCM WeOeW WeeOD 684 | Sugar Free Starlight Mints*** OD@O@O®E) □□□□□ DDOD |OODG Wa®OOdDD WOOD 680 | Peanut Butter Cup*** -K, G @OQO@® Gi) □□□□□ DODD WAG WOOD) |O®OO®D 682 | Snickers*** -K O®DO@® □□ 1.37 DOO@OA ©®@O® (DBOO® 678 |M & M Peanut*** -K OD@®® 1.371 DOOG MOOD! MOCO POO 6922 | Kit Kat***-K OD@@®@ Eq) □□□□□ DOo®d MW®2OD DBOOQ WeOeO®D 1064 | Hershey Milk Bar***- K, G D@O@O@®@G) 1.37\ DOOD MOODM MOOD WOOD 694 | Twix Bar *** -K O@ODO@®@e® □□□□□ DOOD MOOG MOOG Woom Wded OGG W®deoe 1066 | Fruit Chews*** O®DO@®GE®) 0.82 2060 | Neon Worms*** @O@@®@® @) 1.13) TY FL rid rt | | 673 | Jolly Rancher*** @O®D@O@®DE) □□□□□ 681 | Skittles** D@DO@DSG} 1.37} [GoGo (Maha 0146 | Cashews***-K,G D@®®@® 1.95 DOOD | MOOG Weeq WeOo 2260 | Healthy Snack Mbc** -K,H,S DOO@O@®E@ 1.28 DQO@DD OOD! ODD @®2Oe® 1072 | Cough Drape Loc |DQO@De 111 DOOD WOOD) M®2®® MOOeOo® | BEVERAGES: D@OO® @OO® @2@OOaqQ @eeoe 700-7 Deca Peewee fo □□ DODO □□□□ 428i DOOD |POOD ®©OOO|) OOO _1 |} 55 Geet SofieeiC\H D@OOD@DE@| 4.85 DOOO® |POOD) WOOD O®O@OA \TAS | Maxwell Hodse SetectiRoast- H,G DOO®@DD® 3.96 DOOD MOODOA BOO®D area oh Cy Hoy Gocaala Hf DO®@O® 2.36 DOOD MOOD WMWOeO@ePDMOaae® 1074 | Kool Aid Watarelun/Strawberry Drink***-K,H,G O@M@@® 2.051 HOOD @We@®ed® WAe¢) Boog ThB\| Caphupeine tis) H OD@®@O®) 2.15) — ~~ iy A 724 | Nein Walry C aie? Ghsar Pouch -K, H ODOO@® 1.41 FOOD ITEMS Ye VFN 1 1028 | Ory Mik Poyen, DOO@DE®) 4.241 | Obrien's Beal Slick- G* QO GO GB P65] \ |S724| Sugar Cleat Pouch -K,H @D 1.43) | Cajun Rice Chicken & Sausage-G GD\D Gian Gj 411 722! | Tea Bags, Golden Tip-K (D®®®@®) □□□□□ Salt (0.37) Pepper (1.15) te (3) GB |__|. | Honey -K, S DOOOeq □□□□□ Chopped Onion (1.55) Garlic Powdery (2.55) (i) | | 2098 | Sugar Twin -K D@® @®@@ 3.25 | Spanish Rice \ DG) @ 0.65 2182 | S.F. Tampico Mango Drink***-G,S,K □□□□□ □□□□ | Philadelphia Cream Cheese with Jalaperio’ \ |G) @\4a7q@ dd) 0.05) 728 | Sugar Free Wylers Drink Mix Assorted***-K |D@@@@®)| 1,573 630 | White Long Grain Rice -K DODO □□ 1.11 2256 | Healthy Shake Mix, Vanilla or Chocolate** |(D@@@M □□ 1.36) | Chorizo Sausage- G DO@O@®* 2.11 7022 | Tang Breakfast Drink Mix***K,H,G DO®D@®O@® 1.95) | Beef in BBO DOO@O®) 4.25 1053 | Creamer French Vanitla- I<, H DODD □ □□□ 2.15) 598 | Beef Stew- G DQOO@D 2.08} |_ SNACKS, Pi Cc \L and CHIPS 59 | Hot Beef Sausage DOO@®) 2.16 1035 | Granola Bar, Oats & Honey*** @®@®®@® @ 0.65} 719 | Summer Sausage -H DO@O@OEe| 2.64 □ BBQ Sauce (2.57) Parmesan Cheese Blend (1.72) 721 | Honey Roasted Peanuts *** D@®D® @ 0.82 11 | Turkey Sausage -S DO@O@® 2.63 765 | Trail Mix, Sweet and Salty *** -K, G DO@®@E® 1.63 624 | Sliced Pepperoni*** DO@O@e 2.21 687 | Salted Peanuts*** -K, S, G D@O@O@G® 241 606 | Sliced Salami*** D®O@®O@Ee)} 2.21 733 | Saltine Crackers -K, H, S DO@®@O@E® 2.401 8222 | Beef Taco Filling-G DO ® 2.48 2173 | Town House Cracker- K @O®O@e® □□ 2.771 540 | Chili with Beans DOO@O® 2.18 778 | Graham Crackers -K O@DO®® @} 4.221 5722 | Southwest Black Beans and Beef DO®@@® 2.80 1722 | Strawberry Creme Wafer S.F. -K,H,G DO®®® @ 1.08) 627 | Pork, Jerk Style - S, G D®@®@ @E) 4.01 2050 | Coffee Cakes, Zippy Cakes***-K @@®@® □□ 0.86) 587 | Chicken Breast -S, G DO@®O@Oe 1.64 2189 | Oreo Cookies, 6PK***-K @@OO®@® By 0.62) Mrs. Dash Original (3.27) Adobo (2.15) \) @ gay 662 | Honey Bun*** -K ®@O®® @ 1.08} 6322 | Hot Sauce Squeezers -K,G DO@®D@®@ Eel 0.94 616 | Cream Cheese Cake*** -K O@O@O® □□ 0.91} San Miguel Salsa Verde-K (1.17) Tomato Sauce (1.30) Qe Mes 2120 | Danish Iced Cinnamon Swirl***-K QOO® □ 0.93) 640 | Mayonnaise, Bottle -K De® 3.68) 654 | Fudge Stripe Cookies-K DOOD®D® 4.371 4622 | Ketchup Bottle-K,G O® 2.08) 2284 | Chocolate Chip Cookies*** @D@O@O® □□ 0.58) 596 | Ranch Dressing, Kraft DOOD? 043 0190 | Cupcakes, Chocolate Cream***- K DO@O® □ 1.23 0124 | Goya Sazon -G DOO@®® 148 655 | Iced Oatmeal Cookie -K, H OD □□ □□□ □□ □□□□□ 637 | Bagel*** -K, H, S DOOODQ 162 1104 | Duplex Creme Cookies -K, H DO®® @ 1.90) 2645 | Cinnamon Raisin Bagel*** DD ®D® 0.52 669 | Sandwich Crackers, Assorted***-K D ®D □ ® □□□ 0.49 Spread -G, S (3.84) Grape Jelly Bottle-G (385) @& 0138 | Sliced Jalapeno Peppers-K,H,G 1,92 2084 | Frosted Flakes Cereal-K D@OO®® G® □□□□□ Elour Tortillas - K,H,S (1.32) Fajita Seasoning (1.36) Be @®s 758 | Golden Valley Raisin Bran- K, S DA®D®E® 4.37 2022 | Louisiana Wing Sauce - K D@ 2.20 770 | Honey Nut Toasted Oats Cereal - K, S DDO®DG 4.83) 24 | Marshmallow Cream- K D@®O@®@® Bj 1.75) | 6222] Creamy Fruit, tnstant Oatmeal-K OD®D®GE® 3.68} 622 | Peanut Butter -K,H,S DO®D@®) 3.67 621 | Instant Oatmeal Variety Pack- K, S DO@@®@® □□□ 2.72} Cheddar Squeeze Cheese, Jalapeno Squeeze CheeseG GG 3.63 689 | Pretzels Mini Twists-K D@OOD®DE®) 2.71} 585 | Provolone Cheese Bar - G D@@®@® B®} 1.60) | 7722| Cheetos Cheese Crunchy-G DO@®O@®@ Gil 2.44 2155 | Hot Pepper Cheese Bar- G,H,S, K DOO@® 1.60 1110 | Tortilla Chips- K, H DOO@®E®) 2.48 590 | Mackerel -H, S >@O@D@ ah 2.00 754 | Doritos DO@@® @ @ 2.201 636 | Tuna -K, H, S D@@®D © TH 2.80) 753 | Ripple Chips-K,H,G @D@@®@® @i 1.56 547 | Sardines in Soya Oil -H, S D@@®D © gw 1.17 735 | Sour Cream Chip -K, H DO@®® 1.56 | Qaleaene Dlabase Wl em ran ren re CET, 9 ADD lADRAlLAn Chahkana Mhinan Le LI (AN (BN □□□ CA □□□ 4 □□□