Markowicz v. Johnson



81,7('67$7(6',675,&7&2857 )257+(',675,&72)&2/80%,$

0,&+$(/0$5.2:,&=      3ODLQWLII     &LYLO$FWLRQ1R   5&

  Y     5H'RFXPHQW1R   -(+&+$5/(6-2+1621  Secretary, United States Department of  Homeland Security      'HIHQGDQW 

0(025$1'8023,1,21

*5$17,1*,13$57$1''(1<,1*,13$57'()(1'$17¶6027,2172',60,66 25,17+($/7(51$7,9()256800$5<-8'*0(17

,,1752'8&7,21

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

,QDSUHDQVZHUPRWLRQWKH'HSDUWPHQWPRYHVWRGLVPLVV6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶V FRPSODLQWDQGPRYHVLQWKHDOWHUQDWLYHIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWLQLWVIDYRURQ6SHFLDO$JHQW 0DUNRZLF]¶VFODLPV%HFDXVH6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]KDVZLWKGUDZQKLVUHWDOLDWLRQFODLPWKH &RXUWZLOOGLVPLVVWKDWFODLP%XWEHFDXVH6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VFRPSODLQWVWDWHVD SODXVLEOHGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLPDQGEHFDXVHJHQXLQHLVVXHVRIPDWHULDOIDFWH[LVWZLWKUHVSHFWWR   WKDWFODLPIRUWKHSDUWLHVWRH[SORUHLQGLVFRYHU\WKH&RXUWGHFOLQHVWRJUDQWWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶V PRWLRQZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLP

,,%$&.*5281'

$7KH6HFUHW6HUYLFH

2UJDQL]DWLRQDO6WUXFWXUH

7KH6HFUHW6HUYLFHLVDQRSHUDWLRQDOFRPSRQHQWZLWKLQWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'HSDUWPHQWRI +RPHODQG6HFXULW\SeeOperational and Support Components86'HS¶WRI+RPHODQG6HF KWWSVZZZGKVJRYRSHUDWLRQDODQGVXSSRUWFRPSRQHQWVODVWXSGDWHG-XQH see also 86&†86&†J 7KH'LUHFWRURIWKH6HFUHW6HUYLFHOHDGVWKHDJHQF\DORQJ ZLWKD'HSXW\'LUHFWRUZKRPDQDJHVLWVGDLO\SURWHFWLYHDQGLQYHVWLJDWLYHRSHUDWLRQVSee Leadership86'HS¶WRI+RPHODQG6HFKWWSZZZVHFUHWVHUYLFHJRYDERXWOHDGHUVKLSODVW YLVLWHG6HSW 

:LWKLQWKH6HFUHW6HUYLFH$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRUVPDQDJHYDULRXVRIILFHVZLWKWKHKHOSRI WKHLU'HSXW\$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRUVSee generally'HI¶V0RW'LVPLVVRULQWKH$OWHUQDWLYHIRU 6XPP-³'HI¶V0RW´ ([&(&)1ROLVWLQJWKH$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRUVLQ'HFHPEHU DQGWKH$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRUV¶UHVSHFWLYHRIILFHVVXFKDVWKH³2IILFHRI$GPLQLVWUDWLRQ´DQGWKH

  $WWKHPRWLRQWRGLVPLVVVWDJHWKH&RXUWSUHVXPHVWKDWWKHSODLQWLII¶VIDFWXDO DOOHJDWLRQVLQWKHFRPSODLQWDUHWUXHSee, e.g.United States v. Philip Morris, Inc.)6XSS G ''&

:KHQFLWLQJWRGRFXPHQWVRXWVLGHRIWKHSOHDGLQJVWKH&RXUWYLHZV WKHHYLGHQFHLQWKHOLJKWPRVWIDYRUDEOHWR6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]SeeAnderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc.86  

 H[SODLQLQJWKDWRQVXPPDU\MXGJPHQW³>W@KHHYLGHQFHRI WKHQRQPRYDQWLVWREHEHOLHYHGDQGDOOMXVWLILDEOHLQIHUHQFHVDUHWREHGUDZQLQKLVIDYRU´

7KH &RXUWFLWHVWRWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶V6WDWHPHQWRI8QGLVSXWHG0DWHULDO)DFWV(&)1R ZKHQLW DJUHHVZLWK6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VFRPSODLQW  7KH&RXUWWDNHVMXGLFLDOQRWLFHRILQIRUPDWLRQSRVWHGRQRIILFLDOSXEOLFZHEVLWHVRI JRYHUQPHQWDJHQFLHVSee Pharm. Research & Mfrs. of Am. v. U.S. Dep’t of Health & Human Servs.)6XSSG ''&



 

 ³2IILFHRI,QYHVWLJDWLRQV´ 0DJDZ'HFOˆˆ±±(&)1RGLVFXVVLQJ'HSXW\ $VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU0DJDZ¶VUROHZLWKLQWKH2IILFHRI6WUDWHJLF,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG,QIRUPDWLRQDQG KRZKHDVVLVWHGWKH$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRUIRUWKDWRIILFH :LWKLQHDFKRIILFH6SHFLDO$JHQWVLQ &KDUJH³6$,&V´ PDQDJHYDULRXVGLYLVLRQVSee, e.g.(OLDV'HFOˆ(&)1RQRWLQJWKDW 6$,&1HOVRQ*DUDELWRPDQDJHGWKH3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQ :LWKLQ HDFKGLYLVLRQPXOWLSOH$VVLVWDQWVWRWKH6SHFLDO$JHQWLQ&KDUJH³$76$,&V´ PD\DVVLVWWKH 6$,&LQPDQDJLQJWKHZRUNIRUWKHGLYLVLRQSee, e.g.*DUDELWR'HFO(&)1R GLVFXVVLQJWKHWKUHH$76$,&SRVLWLRQVDYDLODEOHZLWKLQWKH3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG $VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQLQ2FWREHU id.ˆGLVFXVVLQJKRZWKH'LYLVLRQVRXJKWWRKLUH $76$,&VWRVXSHUYLVHZRUNSHUIRUPHGE\WKH'LYLVLRQ¶V2SHUDWLRQV&HQWHU $76$,&VLQWXUQ VXSHUYLVH6SHFLDO$JHQWVSee, e.g.0DUNRZLF]6HSW'HFOˆ3O¶V2SS¶Q'HI¶V0RW 'LVPLVVRULQWKH$OWHUQDWLYHIRU6XPP-³3O¶V2SS¶Q´ ([$(&)1RQRWLQJWKDW 6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VILUVWOLQHVXSHUYLVRULQZDV$76$,&5REHUW/RQJ 

0HULW3URPRWLRQ3ODQIRU*6DQG*66SHFLDO$JHQW3RVLWLRQV

6HFUHW6HUYLFH6SHFLDO$JHQWVFRPSHWHIRUSURPRWLRQWRSRVLWLRQVDWJUDGHOHYHOV*6 DQG*6ZKLFKLQFOXGH$76$,&SRVLWLRQVSee'HI¶V0RW([$DW±(&)1R UHSURGXFLQJWKH6HFUHW6HUYLFH¶VPHULWSURPRWLRQSODQIRU6SHFLDO$JHQWSRVLWLRQVZKLFKVWDWHV WKDW³>F@RPSHWLWLYHSURFHGXUHVDSSO\WRSURPRWLRQVIRUJUDGHOHYHOV*6DQG*6´ see, e.g.$P&RPSO³&RPSO´ ˆ(&)1RVWDWLQJWKDWDQ$76$,&YDFDQF\LQWKH2IILFHRI 6WUDWHJLF,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG,QIRUPDWLRQ¶V3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQZDV FODVVLILHGDWWKH*6OHYHO ,IWKH\FKRRVHWRSDUWLFLSDWHLQWKHSURPRWLRQSURFHVV6SHFLDO

  %HFDXVH³>D@SDUW\PD\DPHQGLWVSOHDGLQJRQFHDVDPDWWHURIFRXUVHZLWKLQ GD\VDIWHUVHUYLQJLW´)HG5&LY3 D



6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶V$PHQGHG&RPSODLQW LVWKHRSHUDWLYHFRPSODLQWKHUHSee$IIRI0DLOLQJ(&)1R LQGLFDWLQJWKDW6SHFLDO$JHQW  

 $JHQWVUHFHLYHD0HULW3URPRWLRQ3ODQ³033´ VFRUH&RPSOˆ'HI¶V6WDWHPHQWRI 8QGLVSXWHG0DWHULDO)DFWV³'HI¶V6WDWHPHQW´ ˆ(&)1R7KH033VFRUHIRUHDFK6SHFLDO $JHQWLVDZHLJKWHGVFRUHWKDWLQFRUSRUDWHVUDZVFRUHVJHQHUDWHGE\

 WKHHYDOXDWLRQRIWKH6SHFLDO$JHQWWKDWWKH6SHFLDO$JHQW¶VVXSHUYLVRUFRPSOHWHV

 DQ³LQEDVNHW´DVVHVVPHQWGHVLJQHGWRVLPXODWHWKH6SHFLDO$JHQW¶VUHYLHZRI

PDWHULDOVW\SLFDOO\IRXQGLQD*6RU*66SHFLDO$JHQW¶V³LQEDVNHW´DQGWKXV

GHVLJQHGWRDVVHVVKRZWKH6SHFLDO$JHQW³ZRXOGPDNHGHFLVLRQVDERXWGHOHJDWLQJ

UHVSRQVLELOLW\´DQGDERXWSULRULWL]LQJLQIRUPDWLRQRUVLWXDWLRQVSUHVHQWHG

 DYLGHREDVHGVLWXDWLRQDOMXGJPHQWWHVWDQG

 WUDLQHGUDWHUVZKRHYDOXDWHDQGVFRUHWKH6SHFLDO$JHQW¶V³&DUHHU$FFRPSOLVKPHQW

5HFRUG´ 'HI¶V0RW([$DW±

6SHFLDO$JHQWVXVHWKHLU033VFRUHVWRDSSO\IRU*6DQG*6SRVLWLRQVE\ELGGLQJ RQDQQRXQFHGYDFDQFLHV&RPSOˆ'HI¶V6WDWHPHQWˆsee'HI¶V0RW([$DW GLVFXVVLQJWKHELGGLQJSURFHVV $IWHUUHFHLYLQJ6SHFLDO$JHQWV¶ELGVWKH6HFUHW6HUYLFH¶V 3HUVRQQHO'LYLVLRQWKHQUHIHUVWKUHHJURXSVRIHOLJLEOHSURPRWLRQFDQGLGDWHVIRUFRQVLGHUDWLRQ ZLWKUHVSHFWWRHDFKYDFDQF\

 DOO6SHFLDO$JHQWVZKRELGRQWKDWVSHFLILFYDFDQF\DQGZKRDUHFXUUHQWO\VHUYLQJLQ

DUROHWKDWLVDWRUDERYHWKHJUDGHOHYHORIWKHYDFDQF\

 WKHKLJKHVWUDQNLQJWKLUW\6SHFLDO$JHQWVZKRELGRQWKDWVSHFLILFYDFDQF\DQG

 0DUNRZLF]VHUYHGKLVLQLWLDOFRPSODLQWRQ$XJXVW

&RPSO VKRZLQJWKDW6SHFLDO $JHQW0DUNRZLF]ILOHGKLV$PHQGHG&RPSODLQWZKLFKLQFOXGHVDQH[KLELWDWWKHHQGRIWKH GRFXPHQWRQ$XJXVWRUIRXUGD\VDIWHUKHVHUYHGKLVLQLWLDOFRPSODLQW



 



 WKHKLJKHVWUDQNLQJWKLUW\6SHFLDO$JHQWVRYHUDOOZKRELGRQDQ\YDFDQFLHVDWWKH

VDPHJUDGHOHYHODVWKHYDFDQF\EHLQJFRQVLGHUHGe.g.IRUD*6YDFDQF\WKH

KLJKHVWUDQNLQJWKLUW\6SHFLDO$JHQWVZKRELGRQany*6YDFDQFLHV  See'HI¶V0RW([$DW7KHVHWKUHHOLVWVDUHFDOOHGWKH³5HDVVLJQPHQW&HUWLILFDWH´WKH ³3URPRWLRQ&HUWLILFDWH´DQGWKH³3URPRWLRQ5HJLVWHU´UHVSHFWLYHO\See&RPSOˆˆ±'HI¶V 6WDWHPHQWˆˆ±6SHFLDO$JHQWV¶033VFRUHVGHWHUPLQHWKHLUSRVLWLRQVRQWKHUDQNHGOLVWV &RPSOˆ

)RUHDFKDQQRXQFHGYDFDQF\WKH6HFUHW6HUYLFH¶V$GYLVRU\%RDUGUHFHLYHVWKHWKUHHOLVWV GHVFULEHGDERYHDQGIURPWKHPUHFRPPHQGVD6SHFLDO$JHQWIRUSURPRWLRQSee'HI¶V0RW ([$DW7KH%RDUG¶VPHPEHUVKLSLQFOXGHVWKH6HFUHW6HUYLFH¶V'HSXW\'LUHFWRUWKH $VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRUVWKH&KLHIRIWKH8QLIRUPHG'LYLVLRQDQGWKH&KLHI&RXQVHOZLWKWKH&KLHI RIWKH3HUVRQQHO'LYLVLRQLQDWWHQGDQFHEXWIXQFWLRQLQJDVDQDGYLVRUDQGVHFUHWDU\Seeid. 'HI¶V0RW([&OLVWLQJWKH%RDUG¶VPHPEHUVKLSLQ'HFHPEHU $IWHUUHFHLYLQJWKH %RDUG¶VUHFRPPHQGDWLRQWKH'LUHFWRURIWKH6HFUHW6HUYLFHPD\FKRRVHWRFRQFXUZLWKWKH UHFRPPHQGDWLRQRUWRVHOHFWDQRWKHU6SHFLDO$JHQWIRUSURPRWLRQIURPRQHRIWKHWKUHHOLVWVSee 'HI¶V0RW([$DW

7KH%RDUG¶VUHFRPPHQGDWLRQSURFHVVWDNHVLQWRDFFRXQWWKHYLHZVRIWKHRIILFHDQGRI WKHGLYLVLRQDIIHFWHGE\WKHYDFDQF\$WWKHPHHWLQJDWZKLFKWKH%RDUGFRQVLGHUVZKLFK6SHFLDO $JHQWWRUHFRPPHQGIRUDJLYHQYDFDQF\WKH$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRURIWKHRIILFHDIIHFWHGE\WKH YDFDQF\ZLOOUHFRPPHQGRQHRUPRUH6SHFLDO$JHQWVIRUWKHYDFDQF\0DJDZ'HFOˆ7KH $VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU¶VUHFRPPHQGDWLRQW\SLFDOO\UHVXOWVIURPGLVFXVVLRQVDERXWWKHYDFDQF\ EHWZHHQWKH$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRUKLVRUKHU'HSXW\$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRUDQGWKH6SHFLDO$JHQWLQ &KDUJH³6$,&´ RIWKHGLYLVLRQDIIHFWHGE\WKHYDFDQF\See, e.g.(OLDV'HFOˆVWDWLQJWKDW

 

 6$,&*DUDELWRKDGLQSXWLQWR$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU(OLDV¶VUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVWRWKH$GYLVRU\ %RDUG *DUDELWR'HFOˆ±VDPH 0DJDZ'HFOˆVDPH 

%$76$,&9DFDQFLHVLQWKH3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQ RIWKH2IILFHIRU6WUDWHJLF,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG,QIRUPDWLRQ

9DFDQF\$QQRXQFHPHQW

2Q2FWREHUWKH6HFUHW6HUYLFH¶V3HUVRQQHO'LYLVLRQDQQRXQFHGDYDFDQF\IRUDQ $VVLVWDQWWRWKH6SHFLDO$JHQWLQ&KDUJH³$76$,&´ LQWKH3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG $VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQLQWKH6HFUHW6HUYLFH¶V2IILFHIRU6WUDWHJLF,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG,QIRUPDWLRQ &RPSOˆ'HI¶V6WDWHPHQWˆ7KHDQQRXQFHPHQWFRUUHVSRQGHGWRWKUHHYDFDQW$76$,& SRVLWLRQVLQWKDWGLYLVLRQSee*DUDELWR'HFOˆGLVFXVVLQJWKHWKUHH$76$,&YDFDQFLHVLQWKH 3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQ¶V2SHUDWLRQV&HQWHU 

&DQGLGDWHV

$OWKRXJK6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]ELGRQWKH$76$,&YDFDQF\KHXOWLPDWHO\ZDVQRW VHOHFWHGIRUSURPRWLRQWRDQ\RIWKHWKUHHRSHQSRVLWLRQV&RPSOˆˆ'HI¶V6WDWHPHQW ˆˆ%HFDXVHKLVQRQVHOHFWLRQIRUPVWKHEDVLVRIWKLVVXLWsee&RPSOˆWKH&RXUW VXPPDUL]HVKHUHWKHTXDOLILFDWLRQVRI6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]DQGRIVHYHUDORIKLV FRPSHWLWRUVIRUWKH$76$,&YDFDQFLHVDWWKHWLPHWKH\VXEPLWWHGWKHLUELGV

a. Thomas Edwards

6SHFLDO$JHQW7KRPDV(GZDUGVZDVUDQNHGILUVWRQWKH3URPRWLRQ&HUWLILFDWHIRUWKH 3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQ$76$,&YDFDQFLHVSee'HI¶V0RW([% (&)1RUHSURGXFLQJWKH3URPRWLRQ&HUWLILFDWH +HZDVUDQNHGWZHOIWKRQWKHQDWLRQZLGH 3URPRWLRQ5HJLVWHUSee&RPSO([(&)1R$FFRUGLQJWR6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶V FRPSODLQW³6HFUHW6HUYLFHSHUVRQQHOUHFRUGVUHYHDO>@WKDW>6SHFLDO$JHQW(GZDUGV@OLVWVKLVUDFH DV+LVSDQLF´HYHQWKRXJKKH³ZDVSUHYLRXVO\LGHQWLILHGDV>Z@KLWH´&RPSOˆ

 



6SHFLDO$JHQW(GZDUGV¶VH[SHULHQFHLQFOXGHGIRXU\HDUVDQGVHYHQPRQWKVLQWKH6HFUHW 6HUYLFH¶V6DQ'LHJR)LHOG2IILFHIRXU\HDUVLQWKH9LFH3UHVLGHQWLDO3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQIRXU PRQWKVDWWKH5RZOH\7UDLQLQJ&HQWHUWZR\HDUVDQGRQHPRQWKLQWKH2IILFHRI*RYHUQPHQW DQG3XEOLF$IIDLUVDQGVL[PRQWKVLQWKH:DVKLQJWRQ)LHOG2IILFH&RPSO([accord'HI¶V 0RW([%,QWRWDOKHKDGHOHYHQ\HDUVDQGVL[PRQWKVRIH[SHULHQFHDVD6SHFLDO$JHQWSee &RPSO([%XWKHSURYLGHGSURWHFWLYHVHUYLFHVGXULQJRQO\KLVIRXU\HDUVLQWKH9LFH 3UHVLGHQWLDO3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQSeeid.6SHFLDO$JHQW(GZDUGVZDVSURPRWHGWRRQHRIWKH YDFDQW$76$,&SRVLWLRQVLQWKH3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQSee&RPSO ˆˆ±'HI¶V6WDWHPHQWˆˆ±

b. Nathan Morgan

6SHFLDO$JHQW1DWKDQ0RUJDQZDVUDQNHGVHFRQGRQWKH3URPRWLRQ&HUWLILFDWHSee 'HI¶V0RW([%+HKDGDWRWDORIHOHYHQ\HDUVDQGQLQHPRQWKVRIH[SHULHQFHDVD6SHFLDO $JHQWRIZKLFKKHVSHQWWKUHH\HDUVDQGWHQPRQWKVSURYLGLQJSURWHFWLYHVHUYLFHVWKURXJKWKH 3UHVLGHQWLDO3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQSeeid.%HFDXVHWKH$GYLVRU\%RDUGFKRVHWRUHFRPPHQG 6SHFLDO$JHQW0RUJDQIRUDSURPRWLRQSRVLWLRQLQDGLIIHUHQW6HFUHW6HUYLFHRIILFHWKH$GYLVRU\ %RDUGGLGQRWUHFRPPHQGKLPIRUSURPRWLRQWRDQ$76$,&SRVLWLRQLQWKH3URWHFWLYH ,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQSee(OLDV'HFOˆ0DJDZ'HFOˆ

c. Razvan Simonica

6SHFLDO$JHQW5D]YDQ6LPRQLFDZDVUDQNHGWKLUGRQWKH3URPRWLRQ&HUWLILFDWHSee 'HI¶V0RW([%+HKDGDWRWDORIWZHOYH\HDUVDQGQLQHPRQWKVDVD6SHFLDO$JHQWRIZKLFK KHVSHQWIRXU\HDUVSURYLGLQJSURWHFWLYHVHUYLFHVWKURXJKWKH9LFH3UHVLGHQWLDO3URWHFWLYH 'LYLVLRQSeeid./LNH6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]6SHFLDO$JHQW6LPRQLFDZDVQRWUHFRPPHQGHG IRUSURPRWLRQWRRQHRIWKH$76$,&SRVLWLRQVLQWKH3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW

 

 'LYLVLRQSee(OLDV'HFOˆˆ0DJDZ'HFOˆ%XWHYHQWKRXJK6SHFLDO$JHQW6LPRQLFD ZDVQRWSURPRWHGWRRQHRIWKRVHSRVLWLRQVKHZDVSURPRWHGWRDQRWKHUSRVLWLRQGXULQJWKHVDPH SURPRWLRQF\FOHSee0DUNRZLF]6HSW'HFOˆ

d. Plaintiff Michael Markowicz

6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]ZDVUDQNHGILIWKRQWKH3URPRWLRQ&HUWLILFDWHIRUWKH 3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQ$76$,&YDFDQFLHVsee'HI¶V0RW([%DQG WZHQW\ILIWKRQWKHQDWLRQZLGH3URPRWLRQ5HJLVWHUsee&RPSO([+HLVZKLWH0DUNRZLF]6HSW 'HFOˆ

6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VH[SHULHQFHLQFOXGHGILYH\HDUVDQGWKUHHPRQWKVLQWKH +RXVWRQ)LHOG2IILFHWZR\HDUVDQGWKUHHPRQWKVLQWKH:LOOLDP&OLQWRQ3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQ WKUHH\HDUVDQGVL[PRQWKVLQWKH9LFH3UHVLGHQWLDO3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQWKUHH\HDUVLQWKH ,QIRUPDWLRQ5HVRXUFHV0DQDJHPHQW'LYLVLRQDQGRQH\HDULQWKH:DVKLQJWRQ)LHOG2IILFH &RPSO([accord'HI¶V0RW([%see also0DUNRZLF]'HF'HFO3O¶V2SS¶Q([% (&)1RGHVFULELQJ6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VVHUYLFHLQWKH+RXVWRQ)LHOG2IILFHLQWKH 9LFH3UHVLGHQWLDO3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQDQGLQWKH,QIRUPDWLRQ5HVRXUFHV0DQDJHPHQW'LYLVLRQ  ,QWRWDOKHKDGWZHOYH\HDUVRIH[SHULHQFHDVD6SHFLDO$JHQWSee&RPSO([2IWKRVHHLJKW \HDUVDQGWHQPRQWKVZHUHGHYRWHGWRSURWHFWLYHVHUYLFHVKLVWZR\HDUVDQGWKUHHPRQWKVLQWKH :LOOLDP&OLQWRQ3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQKLVWKUHH\HDUVDQGVL[PRQWKVLQWKH9LFH3UHVLGHQWLDO 3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQDQGKLVWKUHH\HDUVLQWKH,QIRUPDWLRQ5HVRXUFHV0DQDJHPHQW'LYLVLRQSee id.1RQHWKHOHVV6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]ZDVQRWUHFRPPHQGHGRUVHOHFWHGIRUSURPRWLRQWR RQHRIWKH$76$,&SRVLWLRQVLQWKH3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQSee&RPSO ˆˆ±'HI¶V6WDWHPHQWˆˆ±

 



e. Jonathan Wynn

6SHFLDO$JHQW-RQDWKDQ:\QQZDVUDQNHGHLJKWHHQWKRQWKH3URPRWLRQ&HUWLILFDWHIRUWKH 3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQ$76$,&YDFDQFLHVSee'HI¶V0RW([% accord&RPSO([+HZDVUDQNHGVHYHQW\ILIWKRQWKHQDWLRQZLGH3URPRWLRQ5HJLVWHUSee &RPSO([6SHFLDO$JHQW:\QQLV$IULFDQ$PHULFDQ(OLDV'HFOˆ*DUDELWR'HFOˆ

6SHFLDO$JHQW:\QQ¶VH[SHULHQFHLQFOXGHGIRXU\HDUVDQGIRXUPRQWKVLQWKH$WODQWD )LHOG2IILFHWZR\HDUVDQGVL[PRQWKVLQWKH,QWHOOLJHQFH'LYLVLRQWKHSUHFXUVRUWRWKH 3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQ IRXU\HDUVDQGVHYHQPRQWKVLQWKH 3UHVLGHQWLDO3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQDQGRQH\HDUDQGHLJKWPRQWKVLQWKH:DVKLQJWRQ)LHOG2IILFH &RPSO([see also'HI¶V0RW([%(OLDV'HFOˆGHVFULELQJ6SHFLDO$JHQW:\QQ¶V H[SHULHQFHLQWKH,QWHOOLJHQFH'LYLVLRQ ,QWRWDOKHKDGWZHOYH\HDUVDQGHOHYHQPRQWKVRI H[SHULHQFHDVD6SHFLDO$JHQWSee&RPSO([2IWKRVHVHYHQ\HDUVDQGHLJKWPRQWKVZHUH GHYRWHGWRSURWHFWLYHVHUYLFHVKLVWZR\HDUVDQGVL[PRQWKVLQWKH,QWHOOLJHQFH'LYLVLRQDQGKLV IRXU\HDUVDQGVHYHQPRQWKVLQWKH3UHVLGHQWLDO3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQSeeid.6SHFLDO$JHQW:\QQ ZDVSURPRWHGWRRQHRIWKHYDFDQW$76$,&SRVLWLRQVLQWKH3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG $VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQSee&RPSOˆˆ±'HI¶V6WDWHPHQWˆˆ±

f. Gregory Naranjo

6SHFLDO$JHQW*UHJRU\1DUDQMRZDVUDQNHGWZHQWLHWKRQWKH3URPRWLRQ&HUWLILFDWHIRUWKH 3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQ$76$,&YDFDQFLHVSee'HI¶V0RW([% accord&RPSO([+HZDVUDQNHGQLQHW\VHFRQGRQWKHQDWLRQZLGH3URPRWLRQ5HJLVWHUSee &RPSO([6SHFLDO$JHQW1DUDQMRLV+LVSDQLF(OLDV'HFOˆ*DUDELWR'HFOˆ

6SHFLDO$JHQW1DUDQMR¶VH[SHULHQFHLQFOXGHGQLQH\HDUVLQWKH0LDPL)LHOG2IILFHRQH \HDUDQGWZRPRQWKVLQWKH,QWHOOLJHQFH'LYLVLRQWKHSUHFXUVRUWRWKH3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG

 

 $VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQ DQGWZR\HDUVDQGILYHPRQWKVLQWKH3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG $VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQ'HI¶V0RW([%see also&RPSO([(OLDV'HFOˆGHVFULELQJWKH ,QWHOOLJHQFH'LYLVLRQ ,QWRWDOKHKDGWZHOYH\HDUVDQGVHYHQPRQWKVRIH[SHULHQFHDVD6SHFLDO $JHQWSee'HI¶V0RW([%2IWKRVHMXVWWKUHH\HDUVDQGVHYHQPRQWKVZHUHGHYRWHGWR SURWHFWLYHVHUYLFHVKLVRQH\HDUDQGWZRPRQWKVLQWKH,QWHOOLJHQFH'LYLVLRQDQGWZR\HDUVDQG ILYHPRQWKVLQWKH3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQSeeid.6SHFLDO$JHQW 1DUDQMRZDVSURPRWHGWRRQHRIWKHYDFDQW$76$,&SRVLWLRQVLQWKH3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG $VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQSee&RPSOˆˆ±'HI¶V6WDWHPHQWˆˆ±

'HOLEHUDWLRQVDQG6HOHFWLRQV

7KHSDUWLHVGRQRWGLVSXWHWKHEDVLFIDFWVDERXWWKHIDWHRIWKHVH6SHFLDO$JHQWV¶ SURPRWLRQDSSOLFDWLRQV7KH$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRUIRUWKH2IILFHRI6WUDWHJLF,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG ,QIRUPDWLRQ5LFKDUG(OLDVUHFRPPHQGHG6SHFLDO$JHQWV(GZDUGV:\QQDQG1DUDQMRIRU SURPRWLRQWRWKH$76$,&SRVLWLRQVLQWKH3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQ &RPSOˆ'HI¶V6WDWHPHQWˆsee(OLDV'HFOˆVWDWLQJ$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU(OLDV¶VWLWOH DQGKLVUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVIRUWKHSRVLWLRQV %HFDXVH$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU(OLDVZDVXQDEOHWR DWWHQGWKH$GYLVRU\%RDUGPHHWLQJDWZKLFKWKHSRVLWLRQVZHUHGLVFXVVHGWKHQ'HSXW\$VVLVWDQW 'LUHFWRU&UDLJ0DJDZSUHVHQWHG$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU(OLDV¶VUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVWRWKH%RDUG &RPSOˆ'HI¶V6WDWHPHQWˆ(OLDV'HFOˆˆ±7KH$GYLVRU\%RDUGFRQFXUUHGZLWK $VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU(OLDV¶VUHFRPPHQGDWLRQV&RPSOˆ'HI¶V6WDWHPHQWˆ6SHFLDO$JHQWV (GZDUGV:\QQDQG1DUDQMRZHUHWKHQSURPRWHGWRWKH$76$,&SRVLWLRQVLQWKH3URWHFWLYH ,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQ&RPSOˆ'HI¶V6WDWHPHQWˆ6SHFLDO$JHQW 0DUNRZLF]ZDVQRW&RPSOˆ'HI¶V6WDWHPHQWˆ

 



7KHUHFRUGKRZHYHUFRQWDLQVFRPSHWLQJQDUUDWLYHVRIKRZ$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU(OLDV VHWWOHGRQ6SHFLDO$JHQWV(GZDUGV:\QQDQG1DUDQMRIRUKLVUHFRPPHQGDWLRQV6SHFLDO$JHQW 0DUNRZLF]KDVGHVFULEHGRQHYHUVLRQRIHYHQWVZKLFKGLIIHUVLQVRPHUHVSHFWVIURPWKHYHUVLRQV DGRSWHGE\$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU(OLDVE\'HSXW\$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU0DJDZDQGE\6$,& *DUDELWRWKH6SHFLDO$JHQWLQ&KDUJHIRUWKH3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQ  Compare0DUNRZLF]6HSW'HFOˆwith(OLDV'HFOˆˆ±*DUDELWR'HFOˆˆ 0DJDZ'HFOˆˆ±7KH&RXUWEULHIO\VXPPDUL]HVERWKQDUUDWLYHV

6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VQDUUDWLYHZKLFKLVIRXQGLQKLV0DUFKDGPLQLVWUDWLYH GLVFULPLQDWLRQFRPSODLQWDQGLQKLV6HSWHPEHUGHFODUDWLRQUHSRUWVKLVXQGHUVWDQGLQJDERXW WKHGHOLEHUDWLRQVEDVHGRQLQIRUPDWLRQJOHDQHGIURPWKHLQIRUPDOFRXQVHOLQJSURFHVVWKDWZDV UHTXLUHGEHIRUHKHFRXOGILOHDGLVFULPLQDWLRQFRPSODLQWSee'HI¶V0RW(['DW(&) 1RUHSURGXFLQJ6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VQDUUDWLYHLQKLVDGPLQLVWUDWLYHGLVFULPLQDWLRQ

FRPSODLQW

0DUNRZLF]6HSW'HFOˆUHSURGXFLQJLWLQKLV6HSWHPEHUGHFODUDWLRQ  See generally'HI¶V0RW(['DWLQGLFDWLQJWKDW6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]KDGFRPSOHWHG UHTXLUHG(TXDO(PSOR\PHQW2SSRUWXQLW\³((2´ FRXQVHOLQJEHIRUHKHILOHGKLVDGPLQLVWUDWLYH GLVFULPLQDWLRQFRPSODLQW 6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]UHSRUWVWKDW6$,&*DUDELWRILUVWVXJJHVWHG WKHWKUHHWRSUDQNHGFDQGLGDWHV²6SHFLDO$JHQWV(GZDUGV0RUJDQDQG6LPRQLFD²DVKLV UHFRPPHQGDWLRQVIRUSURPRWLRQWRWKH$76$,&SRVLWLRQVLQKLVGLYLVLRQSee'HI¶V0RW([' DW0DUNRZLF]6HSW'HFOˆsee alsosupra3DUWV,,%D±FGLVFXVVLQJWKHWKUHH WRSUDQNHGFDQGLGDWHV 6$,&*DUDELWRSXUSRUWHGO\³EHOLHYHGWKHVHWREHWKHEHVWTXDOLILHGGXH WRWKHLUUDQNLQJV´'HI¶V0RW(['DWaccord0DUNRZLF]6HSW'HFOˆ

%XWDFFRUGLQJWR6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]6$,&*DUDELWR³FKDQJHGKLVVHOHFWLRQ FULWHULD´DIWHUKHOHDUQHGWKDW³KLVQXPEHURQHVHOHFWLRQZDVJRLQJWREHVHOHFWHGIRU

 

 SURPRWLRQLQKLVGLYLVLRQEXWWKDWWKHRWKHUWZRVXEPLWWHGFDQGLGDWHVZHUHEHLQJ SURPRWHGLQRWKHUGLYLVLRQV´'HI¶V0RW(['DWaccord0DUNRZLF]6HSW'HFOˆ 6$,&*DUDELWRUHSRUWHGO\WKHQVRXJKW³DFDQGLGDWHZKRZRUNHGLQKLVGLYLVLRQDQGDFDQGLGDWH WKDWKDGSUHYLRXV3UHVLGHQWLDO3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQH[SHULHQFH´'HI¶V0RW(['DW accord 0DUNRZLF]6HSW'HFOˆ6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]VWDWHVWKDW6$,&*DUDELWR IHOWWKDW³DQDJHQWIURPZLWKLQKLVRZQGLYLVLRQZRXOGHQKDQFHWKHRYHUDOOPRUDOHRI WKHGLYLVLRQ´DQGWKDW3UHVLGHQWLDO3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQH[SHULHQFHZRXOGEHGHVLUDEOHEHFDXVH DJHQWVLQWKDWGLYLVLRQZRUNFORVHO\ZLWKDJHQWVLQ6$,&*DUDELWR¶VGLYLVLRQ0DUNRZLF]6HSW 'HFOˆsee also'HI¶V0RW(['DWGLVFXVVLQJWKHEHQHILWVRIFDQGLGDWHVZLWK 3UHVLGHQWLDO3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQH[SHULHQFH $VDUHVXOW6SHFLDO$JHQWV(GZDUGV:\QQDQG 1DUDQMRZHUHFKRVHQIRUWKHWKUHH$76$,&SRVLWLRQVLQ6$,&*DUDELWR¶VGLYLVLRQSee'HI¶V 0RW(['DW0DUNRZLF]6HSW'HFOˆ

$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU(OLDV'HSXW\$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU0DJDZDQG6$,&*DUDELWRUHSRUW WKDWWKHGHOLEHUDWLRQVZHUHPRUHG\QDPLFSee(OLDV'HFOˆˆ*DUDELWR'HFOˆˆ± 0DJDZ'HFOˆ$VDQLQLWLDOPDWWHU6$,&*DUDELWRGHQLHGWKDWKHZDVWKHUHFRPPHQGLQJ RIILFLDOIRUWKHWKUHH$76$,&SRVLWLRQVKHVWDWHVWKDWWKRXJKKH³KDGGLVFXVVLRQVZLWKDQG H[SUHVVHG>KLV@SUHIHUHQFHVWR>$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU@(OLDVDQG>'HSXW\$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU@ 0DJDZ´KHZDV³QRWDPHPEHURIWKH$GYLVRU\%RDUGZKLFKPDNHVWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVIRU VHOHFWLRQVIRUSURPRWLRQ´*DUDELWR'HFOˆ$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU(OLDVDQG'HSXW\$VVLVWDQW 'LUHFWRU0DJDZDJUHHZLWKWKLVFKDUDFWHUL]DWLRQSee(OLDV'HFOˆ³6$,&*DUDELWRKDGLQSXW LQWRZKRZDVUHFRPPHQGHGWRWKH$GYLVRU\%RDUG+RZHYHUWKH$GYLVRU\%RDUGDVDZKROH PDNHVWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVIRUVHOHFWLRQ´ 0DJDZ'HFOˆ³>$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU@(OLDVDQG, KDGFRQYHUVDWLRQVZLWK6$,&*DUDELWRFRQFHUQLQJZKRZRXOGEHEHVWVXLWHGIRUWKH

 

 SRVLWLRQ>V@+RZHYHU>W@KH$GYLVRU\%RDUGDVDZKROHPDNHVWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVIRU VHOHFWLRQV´ 

:LWKUHVSHFWWR6$,&*DUDELWR¶VVXSSRVHGILUVWVHWRIUHFRPPHQGDWLRQV6SHFLDO$JHQWV (GZDUGV0RUJDQDQG6LPRQLFD 6$,&*DUDELWRGHQLHVUHFRPPHQGLQJ³WKHWKUHHLQLWLDO QDPHV´EXWKHGRHVDGPLWWKDW$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU(OLDVLQLWLDOO\GHFLGHGWKDWKLVRIILFH³ZRXOG WU\WRJHWWKHLQGLYLGXDOVDWWKHWRSRIWKHOLVWGXULQJWKH$GYLVRU\%RDUGGLVFXVVLRQV´*DUDELWR 'HFOˆ6$,&*DUDELWRUHSRUWVWKDWLQVXSSRUWRIWKDWLQLWLDOVWUDWHJ\³>L@WZDVGLVFXVVHGWKDW VHOHFWLQJWRSFDQGLGDWHVZRXOGLPSURYHWKHTXDOLW\RIWKHVXSHUYLVRUVLQWKHGLYLVLRQDQGUDLVH WKHRYHUDOOSHUFHSWLRQRIWKHGLYLVLRQIRUIXWXUHFDQGLGDWHV´SDUWLFXODUO\JLYHQWKDW³>W@KHWRS FDQGLGDWHVKDGJRRGUHSXWDWLRQVDQGKLJKPHULWSURPRWLRQVFRUHV´Id.$QG'HSXW\$VVLVWDQW 'LUHFWRU0DJDZVWDWHVWKDWKHGLGVXSSRUWWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVRI6SHFLDO$JHQWV(GZDUGVDQG 0RUJDQIRUWKHYDFDQFLHVEHFDXVHKHKDGSUHYLRXVO\ZRUNHGZLWKWKHPDQG³KDGSRVLWLYH H[SHULHQFHVZLWKERWKRIWKHP´0DJDZ'HFOˆ$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU(OLDVOLNHZLVHUHFDOOV GLVFXVVLQJ6SHFLDO$JHQW0RUJDQDVDSRWHQWLDOFDQGLGDWH(OLDV'HFOˆ

$OWKRXJK$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU(OLDV'HSXW\$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU0DJDZDQG6$,&*DUDELWR GRQRWVSHFLI\H[DFWO\ZK\WKH\GHYLDWHGIURPWKHLULQLWLDOVWUDWHJ\$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU(OLDVDQG 'HSXW\$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU0DJDZGRUHSRUWWKDWWKH\FRXOGQRWUHFRPPHQG6SHFLDO$JHQW 0RUJDQIRUDQ$76$,&SRVLWLRQEHFDXVHKHZDV³VHOHFWHGIRUDSRVLWLRQRQWKH3UHVLGHQWLDO 3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQGXULQJWKLVVDPHELGF\FOH´Id.accord0DJDZ'HFOˆ,QGLVFXVVLQJ ZK\WKH\VHWWOHGRQ6SHFLDO$JHQWV:\QQDQG1DUDQMRLQDGGLWLRQWR6SHFLDO$JHQW(GZDUGV  IRUWKH$76$,&SRVLWLRQVWKHWKUHHRIILFLDOVFLWHWKHVDPHUHDVRQVDVWKRVHPHQWLRQHGLQ6SHFLDO $JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VQDUUDWLYH7KH\VWDWHWKDWWKH\UHFRPPHQGHG6SHFLDO$JHQW1DUDQMREHFDXVH KHZDVDVVLJQHGWR6$,&*DUDELWR¶VGLYLVLRQDOUHDG\EHFDXVHKH³ZDVDQH[FHOOHQWSHUIRUPHU

 

 ZLWKLQWKHGLYLVLRQ´DQGEHFDXVH³SURPRWLQJIURPZLWKLQWKH>G@LYLVLRQZRXOGLQFUHDVHPRUDO>H@ DQGPRWLYDWHRWKHUVZLWKLQ>WKHGLYLVLRQ@WRSHUIRUPDWDKLJKFDOLEHU´*DUDELWR'HFOˆ accord(OLDV'HFOˆ0DJDZ'HFOˆˆ$QGWKH\VWDWHWKDWWKH\UHFRPPHQGHG6SHFLDO $JHQW:\QQEHFDXVHKHKDGSUHYLRXVH[SHULHQFHLQWKH3UHVLGHQWLDO3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQDQG EHFDXVHWKH³RYHUZKHOPLQJPDMRULW\RIWKHVXSSRUWSURYLGHG´E\WKH3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG $VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQLVIRUWKH3UHVLGHQWLDO3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQ*DUDELWR'HFOˆaccord (OLDV'HFOˆ0DJDZ'HFOˆ

$VGLVFXVVHGHDUOLHU6SHFLDO$JHQW:\QQZDVUDQNHGHLJKWHHQWKRQWKH3URPRWLRQ &HUWLILFDWHDQG6SHFLDO$JHQW1DUDQMRZDVUDQNHGWZHQWLHWKSee'HI¶V0RW([%supra 3DUWV,,%H±I'HVSLWHQRWEHLQJVHOHFWHGIRUSURPRWLRQ6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]ZDVUDQNHG ILIWKRQWKH3URPRWLRQ&HUWLILFDWHSee'HI¶V0RW([%supra3DUW,,%G

&$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NR¶V6WDWHPHQW

$IWHU6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]OHDUQHGDERXWKLVQRQVHOHFWLRQIRUDQ$76$,&SRVLWLRQ LQWKH3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQKHEHJDQLQTXLULQJDERXWWKHSRVVLEOH UHDVRQVIRUWKDWQRQVHOHFWLRQSee0DUNRZLF]6HSW'HFOˆ$QGKHDOOHJHVWKDWKH UHFHLYHGDVLJQLILFDQWOHDGGXULQJDFDVXDOFRQYHUVDWLRQZLWK*HRUJH/XF]NRWKH6HFUHW 6HUYLFH¶V$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRUIRUWKH2IILFHRI3URIHVVLRQDO5HVSRQVLELOLW\Seeid.GLVFXVVLQJ 6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VFRQYHUVDWLRQZLWK$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NR %\YLUWXHRIKLVWLWOH $VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NRZDVDPHPEHURIWKHSURPRWLRQ$GYLVRU\%RDUGSee'HI¶V0RW ([&VKRZLQJ$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NR¶VWLWOHDQGPHPEHUVKLSRQWKH$GYLVRU\%RDUG $IWHU 6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]DVNHG$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NRDERXWZKHWKHU6SHFLDO$JHQW 0DUNRZLF]¶VQDPHZDV³EODFNEDOOHG´IRUVRPHUHDVRQIURPJHWWLQJSURPRWHGDQGDIWHU6SHFLDO $JHQW0DUNRZLF]PHQWLRQHG³WKHGLVSDULW\LQUDQNLQJRIWKRVHSURPRWHGLQ>KLV@VWHDG´

 

 $VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NRDOOHJHGO\UHVSRQGHGZLWKWKHIROORZLQJVWDWHPHQW³0LNHWKLVLV µRIIWKHUHFRUG¶EXWLIWKHUHLVD%ODFNRUD+LVSDQLFRQWKDWTXDOLILHGOLVWWKHQZHKDYHWR SURPRWHWKHPDKHDGRI\RX´0DUNRZLF]6HSW'HFOˆLQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQPDUNV

RPLWWHG

accord&RPSOˆ

$OWKRXJK$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NRUHPHPEHUVVSHDNLQJZLWK6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF] KHVWDWHVWKDW³GR>HV@QRWUHFDOOPDNLQJWKHµRIIWKHUHFRUGVWDWHPHQW¶DERXWD%ODFNRU+LVSDQLF EHLQJSURPRWHGDKHDGRIKLP´/XF]NR'HFOˆˆ±(&)1R%XWDV6SHFLDO$JHQW 0DUNRZLF]SRLQWVRXW$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NRGRHVQRWH[SOLFLWO\GHQ\WKDWKHPDGHWKH VWDWHPHQWSee&RPSOˆ/XF]NR'HFOˆˆ±

'3URFHGXUDO+LVWRU\

$UPHGZLWK$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NR¶VVWDWHPHQW6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]ILOHGDQ DGPLQLVWUDWLYHGLVFULPLQDWLRQFRPSODLQWDJDLQVWWKH'HSDUWPHQWRI+RPHODQG6HFXULW\DQGWKHQ ILOHGVXLWLQWKLV&RXUWSee&RPSO'HI¶V0RW(['UHSURGXFLQJWKHDGPLQLVWUDWLYH

FRPSODLQW

+LVFRPSODLQWLQWKLV&RXUWDOOHJHGWKDWWKH'HSDUWPHQWYLRODWHG7LWOH9,,RIWKH &LYLO5LJKWV$FWRIE\GLVFULPLQDWLQJDJDLQVWKLPRQWKHEDVLVRIKLVUDFHDQGE\ UHWDOLDWLQJLQUHVSRQVHWRKLVSURWHFWHG7LWOH9,,DFWLYLWLHVSee&RPSOˆˆ±,QLWV

  %HFDXVH6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]KDVZLWKGUDZQKLVUHWDOLDWLRQFODLPIDFWVUHOHYDQWWR WKDWFODLPDUHQRWUHFRXQWHGKHUHSee3O¶V2SS¶Q ³3ODLQWLIIZLWKGUDZV&RXQW,, 5HWDOLDWLRQ´

  3XE/1R7LWOH9,,6WDW± FRGLILHGDVDPHQGHGDW86& ††H±H

  $OWKRXJK6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VFRPSODLQWDOVRDVVHUWVWKDW³WKLVDFWLRQDULVHV XQGHUWKH$JH'LVFULPLQDWLRQLQ(PSOR\PHQW$FW´&RPSOˆKHQHYHUODWHUDVVHUWVDQDJH GLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLPseeid.ˆˆ±7KH'HSDUWPHQWDFFRUGLQJO\DUJXHVWKDW6SHFLDO$JHQW 0DUNRZLF]KDVIDLOHGWRVWDWHDQDJHGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLP0HP6XSS'HI¶V0RW'LVPLVV LQ WKH$OWHUQDWLYHIRU6XPP- ³'HI¶V0HP´

DWQ(&)1R 7KH&RXUWDJUHHVZLWKWKH 'HSDUWPHQWDQGWKHUHIRUHZLOOGLVPLVVDQ\DJHGLVFULPLQDWLRQDOOHJDWLRQVLQWKH$PHQGHG &RPSODLQW

 

 SUHDQVZHUPRWLRQWKH'HSDUWPHQWVHHNVGLVPLVVDORI6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VFRPSODLQWRU LQWKHDOWHUQDWLYHVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWLQLWVIDYRURQKLVFODLPVSee'HI¶V0RW'LVPLVVRULQ WKH$OWHUQDWLYHIRU6XPP-(&)1R

,,,5(7$/,$7,21

$OWKRXJK6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]RSSRVHVGLVPLVVDORIDQGVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWRQKLV GLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLPsee3O¶V2SS¶Q±KHKDVFKRVHQWRZLWKGUDZKLVUHWDOLDWLRQFODLPIURP KLVFRPSODLQWLQUHVSRQVHWRWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VPRWLRQseeid.DW7KH&RXUWZLOOWKHUHIRUH GLVPLVVWKDWFODLPZLWKSUHMXGLFHXQGHU)HGHUDO5XOHRI&LYLO3URFHGXUHD  See generally )HG5&LY3D UHTXLULQJGLVPLVVDOE\FRXUWRUGHUZKHQWKHSODLQWLIIILOHVQHLWKHUD VWLSXODWLRQRIGLVPLVVDOVLJQHGE\DOOSDUWLHVQRUDQRWLFHRIGLVPLVVDOEHIRUHWKHRSSRVLQJSDUW\ VHUYHVHLWKHUDQDQVZHURUDPRWLRQIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQW 

,9',6&5,0,1$7,21

7KH&RXUWWXUQVQRZWRWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VPRWLRQZLWKUHVSHFWWR6SHFLDO$JHQW 0DUNRZLF]¶VGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLP%HFDXVHWKH'HSDUWPHQWGHYRWHVWKHILUVWVHFWLRQRILWVEULHI DUJXLQJIRUGLVPLVVDORIWKHFODLPDQGWKHVHFRQGVHFWLRQDUJXLQJLQWKHDOWHUQDWLYHIRUVXPPDU\ MXGJPHQWLQWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VIDYRUWKH&RXUWDGGUHVVHVWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VGLVPLVVDODUJXPHQWV EHIRUHDGGUHVVLQJLWVVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWDUJXPHQWV

 



$$UJXPHQWVIRU'LVPLVVDO

/HJDO6WDQGDUG

7KH)HGHUDO5XOHVRI&LYLO3URFHGXUHUHTXLUHWKDWDFRPSODLQWFRQWDLQ³DVKRUWDQGSODLQ VWDWHPHQWRIWKHFODLP´LQRUGHUWRJLYHWKHGHIHQGDQWIDLUQRWLFHRIWKHFODLPDQGWKHJURXQGV XSRQZKLFKLWUHVWV)HG5&LY3D  accordErickson v. Pardus86  SHUFXULDP $PRWLRQWRGLVPLVVXQGHU5XOHE  GRHVQRWWHVWDSODLQWLII¶VXOWLPDWH OLNHOLKRRGRIVXFFHVVRQWKHPHULWVUDWKHULWWHVWVZKHWKHUDSODLQWLIIKDVSURSHUO\VWDWHGDFODLP SeeScheuer v. Rhodes86 Brewer v. District of Columbia)6XSS G''& $FRXUWFRQVLGHULQJVXFKDPRWLRQSUHVXPHVWKDWWKHFRPSODLQW¶V IDFWXDODOOHJDWLRQVDUHWUXHDQGFRQVWUXHVWKHPOLEHUDOO\LQWKHSODLQWLII¶VIDYRUSee, e.g.United States v. Philip Morris, Inc.)6XSSG''& 

1HYHUWKHOHVV³>W@RVXUYLYHDPRWLRQWRGLVPLVVDFRPSODLQWPXVWFRQWDLQVXIILFLHQW IDFWXDOPDWWHUDFFHSWHGDVWUXHWRµVWDWHDFODLPWRUHOLHIWKDWLVSODXVLEOHRQLWVIDFH¶´Ashcroft v. Iqbal86 TXRWLQJBell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly86  7KLVPHDQVWKDWDSODLQWLII¶VIDFWXDODOOHJDWLRQV³PXVWEHHQRXJKWRUDLVHDULJKWWRUHOLHI DERYHWKHVSHFXODWLYHOHYHORQWKHDVVXPSWLRQWKDWDOOWKHDOOHJDWLRQVLQWKHFRPSODLQWDUHWUXH HYHQLIGRXEWIXOLQIDFW ´Twombly86DW±FLWDWLRQVDQGIRRWQRWHRPLWWHG  ³7KUHDGEDUHUHFLWDOVRIWKHHOHPHQWVRIDFDXVHRIDFWLRQVXSSRUWHGE\PHUHFRQFOXVRU\

  $OWKRXJKWKH'HSDUWPHQWPRYHVWRGLVPLVVXQGHUERWK)HGHUDO5XOHRI&LYLO3URFHGXUH  E

 DQG)HGHUDO5XOHRI&LYLO3URFHGXUHE  LWUDLVHVRQO\5XOHE 

DUJXPHQWVLQ LWVPRWLRQCompare'HI¶V0RW ³'HIHQGDQWKHUHE\PRYHVWRGLVPLVV3ODLQWLII¶V&RPSODLQW SXUVXDQWWR)HGHUDO5XOHVRI&LYLO3URFHGXUH E

 DQGE  ´

with'HI¶V0HP ± DVVHUWLQJQRDUJXPHQWVDERXWWKH&RXUW¶VMXULVGLFWLRQ

See generally)HG5&LY3  E



 DOORZLQJSDUWLHVWRDVVHUWWKHGHIHQVHRI³ODFNRIVXEMHFWPDWWHUMXULVGLFWLRQ´E\ PRWLRQ

7KH&RXUWWKHUHIRUHUHFLWHVWKHJRYHUQLQJOHJDOVWDQGDUGIRU5XOHE 

PRWLRQVWR GLVPLVVRQO\

 

 VWDWHPHQWV´DUHWKHUHIRUHLQVXIILFLHQWWRZLWKVWDQGDPRWLRQWRGLVPLVVIqbal86DW.$ FRXUWQHHGQRWDFFHSWDSODLQWLII¶VOHJDOFRQFOXVLRQVDVWUXHseeid.QRUPXVWDFRXUWSUHVXPHWKH YHUDFLW\RIWKHOHJDOFRQFOXVLRQVWKDWDUHFRXFKHGDVIDFWXDODOOHJDWLRQVseeTwombly86 DW

,QD7LWOH9,,FDVHKRZHYHULWLVQRWQHFHVVDU\IRUWKHSODLQWLIIWRSOHDGDOOHOHPHQWVRI KLVSULPDIDFLHFDVHLQWKHFRPSODLQWSeeSwierkiewicz v. Sorema N.A.86±  Bryant v. Pepco)6XSSG±''& $7LWOH9,,SODLQWLIIQHHG RQO\DOOHJH³IDFWVWKDWWDNHQDVWUXHUHQGHUKLVFODLPRI>GLVFULPLQDWLRQ@SODXVLEOH´Harris v. D.C. Water & Sewer Auth.)G'&&LU ³,ZDVWXUQHGGRZQIRUDMRE EHFDXVHRIP\UDFH´DFFRPSDQLHGE\IDFWXDODOOHJDWLRQVWKDWUHQGHUWKDWFODLPSODXVLEOHDUH³DOO DFRPSODLQWKDVWRVD\WRVXUYLYHDPRWLRQWRGLVPLVVXQGHU5XOHE  ´Sparrow v. United Air Lines, Inc.)G'&&LU LQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQPDUNVRPLWWHG  Jackson v. Acedo1R:/DW''&$XJ GLVFXVVLQJ SparrowLQOLJKWRIWKH6XSUHPH&RXUW¶VODWHUGHFLVLRQVLQTwomblyDQGIqbal 

$QDO\VLV

$VDQLQLWLDOPDWWHUWKH&RXUWDGGUHVVHVWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VDVVHUWLRQWKDW6SHFLDO$JHQW 0DUNRZLF]GLGQRWUHVSRQGWRWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VGLVPLVVDODUJXPHQWVDVZHOODVWKH 'HSDUWPHQW¶VDFFRPSDQ\LQJVXJJHVWLRQWKDW6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]KDV³WKHUHIRUHFRQFHGHG WKDWGLVPLVVDOLVDSSURSULDWH´5HSO\0HP6XSS'HI¶V0RW'LVPLVVRULQWKH$OWHUQDWLYHIRU

  ,QGHFLGLQJDPRWLRQWRGLVPLVVXQGHU5XOH E



DFRXUWPD\QRWUHO\RQPDWWHUV RXWVLGHWKHSOHDGLQJVZLWKRXWFRQYHUWLQJWKHPRWLRQWRRQHIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQW)HG5&LY 3 G

WKRXJKLWPD\FRQVLGHUGRFXPHQWVDWWDFKHGWRWKHFRPSODLQWDVH[KLELWVGRFXPHQWV LQFRUSRUDWHGE\UHIHUHQFHDQGPDWWHUVRQZKLFKWKHFRXUWPD\WDNHMXGLFLDOQRWLFHAbhe & Svoboda, Inc. v. Chao)G  '&&LU

,QDGGUHVVLQJWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶V DUJXPHQWVIRUGLVPLVVDORI6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLPWKHUHIRUHWKH&RXUW FRQVLGHUVRQO\WKHFRPSODLQWDQGWKHH[KLELWDWWDFKHGWRLWSee&RPSO ([

 

 6XPP-³'HI¶V5HSO\´ (&)1R%XW6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VRSSRVLWLRQEULHI GLUHFWO\UHVSRQGVWRDWOHDVWRQHRIWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VDUJXPHQWVIRUGLVPLVVDOCompare'HI¶V 0HP±DUJXLQJWKDW$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NR¶VVWDWHPHQWLVLUUHOHYDQWWRWKLVFDVHEHFDXVH KH³LVQRWDOOHJHGWRKDYHEHHQWKHVHOHFWLQJRIILFLDOIRUWKHYDFDQF\´DQG³FRXUWVURXWLQHO\KROG WKDWVWDWHPHQWVE\QRQGHFLVLRQPDNHUVDUHQRWSUREDWLYHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQ´ with3O¶V 2SS¶Q±UHVSRQGLQJWRWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VDUJXPHQWE\DVVHUWLQJWKDW$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU /XF]NR¶VFRPPHQW³FDQQRWEHPDUJLQDOL]HG´EHFDXVHKH³ZDVLQFORVHSUR[LPLW\WRWKHVHOHFWLQJ RIILFLDOVZDVLQYROYHGLQWKHVHOHFWLRQSURFHVVDQGLVDILUVWKDQGZLWQHVVWRWKHVHOHFWLRQ FULWHULDRIWKH>$GYLVRU\@%RDUG´ 7KH&RXUWWKHUHIRUHGHFOLQHVWRILQGWKDW6SHFLDO$JHQW 0DUNRZLF]FRQFHGHGWKDWGLVPLVVDOLVDSSURSULDWH7KH&RXUWZLOODFFRUGLQJO\DGGUHVVWKH 'HSDUWPHQW¶VDUJXPHQWVLQIDYRURIGLVPLVVDORQWKHLUPHULWV

7REHJLQWKH&RXUWVXPPDUL]HVVRPHJRYHUQLQJSULQFLSOHV7LWOH9,,GHFODUHVWKDW³>D@OO SHUVRQQHODFWLRQVDIIHFWLQJHPSOR\HHVLQH[HFXWLYHDJHQFLHVVKDOOEHPDGHIUHHIURPDQ\ GLVFULPLQDWLRQEDVHGRQUDFH´86&†HD 7KLVSURYLVLRQH[WHQGVWRIHGHUDO HPSOR\HHV³WKHIXOOULJKWVDYDLODEOHLQWKHFRXUWVDVDUHJUDQWHGWRLQGLYLGXDOVLQWKHSULYDWH VHFWRU´Loeffler v. Frank86± LQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQPDUNVRPLWWHG  TXRWLQJChandler v. Roudebush86 $QGLWDSSOLHVWR6SHFLDO$JHQW 0DUNRZLF]¶VGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLPKHUHSee86&†³µ([HFXWLYHDJHQF\¶PHDQVDQ ([HFXWLYHGHSDUWPHQW´ see alsoid.†³7KH([HFXWLYHGHSDUWPHQWV>LQFOXGH@>W@KH 'HSDUWPHQWRI+RPHODQG6HFXULW\´ 

³7KHSURWHFWLRQVRI7LWOH9,,DSSO\WRPLQRULW\DQGQRQPLQRULW\HPSOR\HHVDOLNH´ Mastro v. Potomac Elec. Power Co.)G'&&LU 7KXV³VLPLODUO\ VLWXDWHGHPSOR\HHVDUHQRWWREHWUHDWHGGLIIHUHQWO\VROHO\EHFDXVHWKH\GLIIHUZLWKUHVSHFWWR

  

 UDFHUHJDUGOHVVRIZKHWKHUWKHGLVFULPLQDWLRQLVGLUHFWHGDJDLQVWPDMRULWLHVRUPLQRULWLHV´Id. LQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQPDUNRPLWWHG TXRWLQJTrans World Airlines, Inc. v. Hardison86 ± %XWEHFDXVH³µWKHUHLVQRWKLQJLQKHUHQWO\VXVSLFLRXV¶DERXWDQHPSOR\HU¶V GHFLVLRQWRSURPRWHDPLQRULW\DSSOLFDQWLQVWHDGRIDZKLWHDSSOLFDQWDPDMRULW\JURXS SODLQWLIIDOOHJLQJ7LWOH9,,GLVFULPLQDWLRQPXVWVKRZµDGGLWLRQDOEDFNJURXQGFLUFXPVWDQFHVWKDW VXSSRUWWKHVXVSLFLRQWKDWWKHGHIHQGDQWLVWKDWXQXVXDOHPSOR\HUZKRGLVFULPLQDWHVDJDLQVWWKH PDMRULW\¶´Id.DWTXRWLQJHarding v. Gray)G'&&LU ³%DFNJURXQG FLUFXPVWDQFHV´PD\VLPSO\EH³VRPHWKLQJµILVK\¶DERXWWKHIDFWVRIWKHFDVHDWKDQGWKDWUDLVHV DQLQIHUHQFHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQ´QRPDWWHUZKHWKHULWLVVRPHWKLQJDERXWWKHHPSOR\HU¶VJHQHUDO EDFNJURXQGRUVRPHWKLQJDERXWWKHSDUWLFXODUIDFWVRIWKHFDVHId.DW±TXRWLQJHarding )GDW 

+HUHWKH'HSDUWPHQWDUJXHVWKDW6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLP ³IDLO>V@WRVWDWHDSODXVLEOHFODLPIRUUHOLHI´'HI¶V0HP,QVXSSRUWRILWVSRVLWLRQWKH 'HSDUWPHQWFLWHV WR6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VIDLOXUHWRDOOHJHWKDWKLVTXDOLILFDWLRQVZHUH IDUVXSHULRUWRWKRVHRI6SHFLDO$JHQW:\QQDQG1DUDQMRDQG WRWKHLGHDWKDW$VVLVWDQW 'LUHFWRU/XF]NR¶VUHPDUNLVLUUHOHYDQWEHFDXVH$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NRZDVQRWWKHXOWLPDWH GHFLVLRQPDNHUZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKH$76$,&SRVLWLRQWRZKLFK6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]DSSOLHG See'HI¶V0HP±

7KH'HSDUWPHQW¶VDVVHUWLRQVKRZHYHUGRQRWDSSUHFLDWHWKHQDUURZQHVVRIWKH&RXUW¶V UROHZKHQGHFLGLQJZKHWKHUWRJUDQWDPRWLRQWRGLVPLVVD7LWOH9,,FODLP7KH³RQO\TXHVWLRQ´ EHIRUHWKH&RXUWQRZ³LVZKHWKHU>6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]@DOOHJHGIDFWVWKDWWDNHQDVWUXH UHQGHUKLVFODLPRI>GLVFULPLQDWLRQ@SODXVLEOH´Harris v. D.C. Water & Sewer Auth.)G '&&LU %HFDXVHWKH&RXUW¶VUROHDWWKLVHDUO\VWDJH³LVQRWWRVSHFXODWHDERXW

 

 ZKLFKIDFWXDODOOHJDWLRQVDUHOLNHO\WREHSURYHGDIWHUGLVFRYHU\´id.WKH&RXUWQHHGQRWDGGUHVV WKHPHULWVRIDQ\SDUWLFXODUPHDQVE\ZKLFK6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]PLJKWSURYHKLVFODLP $IWHUDOO³GLVFRYHU\PD\HYHQXQFRYHUGLUHFWHYLGHQFHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQ´WKDWHOLPLQDWHV6SHFLDO $JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VSRVVLEOHQHHGWRUHO\RQFLUFXPVWDQWLDOHYLGHQFHVXFKDV6SHFLDO$JHQWV 0DUNRZLF]:\QQDQG1DUDQMR¶VUHODWLYHTXDOLILFDWLRQV SeeChappell–Johnson v. Powell )G±'&&LU 

7KXVWKH&RXUWPHUHO\DVVHVVHVZKHWKHU6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]³DOOHJHGIDFWVWKDW WDNHQDVWUXHUHQGHUKLVFODLPSODXVLEOH´Harris)GDW$SSO\LQJWKDWSULQFLSOHWRD 7LWOH9,,FODLPDOOHJLQJUHWDOLDWRU\GLVFKDUJHWKH'&&LUFXLWIRXQGWKDWFODLPSODXVLEOHZKHQ WKHSODLQWLIIKDGPHUHO\DOOHJHG ³DILYHPRQWKJDSEHWZHHQ>KLVHPSOR\HU¶V@NQRZOHGJHRI KLVGLVFULPLQDWLRQFRPSODLQWDQGKLVWHUPLQDWLRQ´ WKDWKLVSHUIRUPDQFHKDGQRWEHHQEHORZ H[SHFWDWLRQVDQG WKDWKLVSRVLWLRQKDGQRWEHHQHOLPLQDWHGId.DW±/LNHZLVHKHUHWKH &RXUWILQGV6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶V7LWOH9,,GLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLPSODXVLEOHJLYHQWKDW 6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]KDVDOOHJHGWKDW WKDWKHZDVQRWSURPRWHG&RPSOˆDQG  WKDWRQO\PLQRULW\6SHFLDO$JHQWV²LQFOXGLQJWZRVLJQLILFDQWO\OHVVHUUDQNHG6SHFLDO $JHQWV²ZHUHSURPRWHGid.ˆˆ ([

0RUHRYHUZKHQDSODLQWLII¶VIDFWV³LIVKRZQZRXOGEHDWOHDVWVXIILFLHQWWRVWDWHDSULPD IDFLHFDVH´WKHSODLQWLIIKDV³QHFHVVDULO\DOOHJHGIDFWVVXIILFLHQWWRUHQGHUKLVFODLPSODXVLEOHDW WKHPRWLRQWRGLVPLVVVWDJH´Harris)GDW+HUHWRPDNHRXWDSULPDIDFLHFDVHRIUDFH GLVFULPLQDWLRQ6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]QHHGRQO\DOOHJH WKDWKHVXIIHUHGDQDGYHUVH HPSOR\PHQWDFWLRQ WKDWWKHXQIDYRUDEOHDFWLRQJLYHVULVHWRDQLQIHUHQFHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQ DQG WKDWEDFNJURXQGFLUFXPVWDQFHVVXSSRUWWKHVXVSLFLRQWKDWWKH6HFUHW6HUYLFHLV³WKDW XQXVXDOHPSOR\HUZKRGLVFULPLQDWHVDJDLQVWWKHPDMRULW\´Mastro v. Potomac Elec. Power Co.

 

 )G±'&&LU seeid.DWH[SODLQLQJWKDWWKH³EDFNJURXQG FLUFXPVWDQFHV´UHTXLUHPHQW³VXEVWLWXWHVIRUWKHPLQRULW\SODLQWLII¶VEXUGHQWRVKRZWKDWKHLVD PHPEHURIDUDFLDOPLQRULW\´LQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQPDUNVRPLWWHG TXRWLQJHarding)GDW  $VGLVFXVVHGEHORZEHFDXVH6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]KDVDOOHJHGDOOWKUHHHOHPHQWVRID SULPDIDFLHUDFHGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLPKHQHFHVVDULO\KDVSOHGDSODXVLEOHFODLPWKDWPXVWVXUYLYH DPRWLRQWRGLVPLVVXQGHU5XOHE  

)LUVWKHDOOHJHGWKDWKHVXIIHUHGDQDGYHUVHHPSOR\PHQWDFWLRQE\DOOHJLQJWKDWWKH 6HFUHW6HUYLFHGHFOLQHGWRSURPRWHKLPWRWKH$76$,&SRVLWLRQIRUZKLFKKHDSSOLHGSeeBaird v. Gotbaum)G'&&LU QRWLQJWKDW³IDLOLQJWRSURPRWH´LVDQDGYHUVH HPSOR\PHQWDFWLRQIRUSXUSRVHVRID7LWOH9,,GLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLPTXRWLQJDouglas v. Donovan)G'&&LU &RPSOˆ

6HFRQG6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]KDVDOOHJHGIDFWVWRVKRZWKDWKLVQRQSURPRWLRQJLYHV ULVHWRDQLQIHUHQFHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQEHFDXVHKHZDVDVTXDOLILHGDVWKH6SHFLDO$JHQWV XOWLPDWHO\SURPRWHGWRWKHSRVLWLRQ³QHLWKHUDQDEVROXWHRUUHODWLYHODFNRITXDOLILFDWLRQVQRUWKH DEVHQFHRIDYDFDQF\LQWKHMREVRXJKWSUHYHQWHG>KLV@SURPRWLRQ´Holcomb v. Powell)G '&&LU see&RPSOˆDOOHJLQJWKDWRWKHU6SHFLDO$JHQWVZHUHVHOHFWHGIRU WKH$76$,&SRVLWLRQ &RPSO([VKRZLQJWKDW6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VTXDOLILFDWLRQV FRPSDUHGIDYRUDEO\WRDWOHDVWVRPHRIWKH6SHFLDO$JHQWVVHOHFWHG See generally Holcomb )GDW±H[SODLQLQJWKDWDSODLQWLIIPDNHVRXWDSULPDIDFLHFDVH²DQGWKHUHE\DOOHJHV IDFWVWKDWJLYHULVHWRDQLQIHUHQFHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQ²E\VKRZLQJWKDWQHLWKHUWKHSODLQWLII¶VODFN RITXDOLILFDWLRQVQRUWKHDEVHQFHRIDYDFDQF\SUHYHQWHGWKHSODLQWLII¶VSURPRWLRQ 

7KLUGDQGILQDOO\6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]KDVDOOHJHGWKHUHTXLVLWHEDFNJURXQG FLUFXPVWDQFHVWRVXSSRUWKLVGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLPLQWZRZD\V E\DOOHJLQJWKDWWKH6HFUHW

 

 6HUYLFHSURPRWHG6SHFLDO$JHQWVZKRVHTXDOLILFDWLRQVZHUHLQIHULRUWRKLVRZQDQG E\ DOOHJLQJWKDW$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NRVWDWHGWKDWUDFLDOFRQVLGHUDWLRQVDIIHFWHGWKHSURPRWLRQ SURFHVVSeeMastro)GDW±H[SODLQLQJWKDW³EDFNJURXQGFLUFXPVWDQFHV´LQFOXGH DQ\HYLGHQFHVKRZLQJWKDW³WKHUHLVVRPHWKLQJµILVK\¶DERXWWKHIDFWVRIWKHFDVH´DQGPD\ LQFOXGH³HYLGHQFHWKDWDPLQRULW\DSSOLFDQWZDVSURPRWHGRYHU>D@EHWWHUTXDOLILHGZKLWH DSSOLFDQW>@´LQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQPDUNVRPLWWHG TXRWLQJHarding)GDW &RPSOˆ GLVFXVVLQJ$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NR¶VVWDWHPHQW &RPSO([VKRZLQJWKDW6SHFLDO$JHQWV :\QQDQG1DUDQMRZHUHUDQNHGORZHUWKDQ6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF] 

%HFDXVHWKH'HSDUWPHQWVSHFLILFDOO\DWWDFNVWKHWZRZD\VWKDW6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF] HVWDEOLVKHV³EDFNJURXQGFLUFXPVWDQFHV´see'HI¶V0HP±WKH&RXUWGLVFXVVHVWKH DOOHJDWLRQVDERXWWKH6SHFLDO$JHQWV¶UHODWLYHTXDOLILFDWLRQVDQGDERXW$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU /XF]NR¶VVWDWHPHQWLQPRUHGHWDLO%XWWKH&RXUWQRWHVDVDSUHOLPLQDU\PDWWHUWKDWHVWDEOLVKLQJ DSULPDIDFLHFDVHRI7LWOH9,,UDFHGLVFULPLQDWLRQLV³QRWRQHURXV´HYHQIRUDZKLWHSODLQWLII Mastro)GDWLQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQPDUNRPLWWHG TXRWLQJTex. Dep’t of Cmty. Affairs v. Burdine86 

:LWKUHVSHFWWRWKHDOOHJDWLRQVDERXWWKH6SHFLDO$JHQWV¶UHODWLYHTXDOLILFDWLRQVWKH 'HSDUWPHQWDUJXHVWKDWWKH\FDQQRWVXJJHVWWKDWDQ\GLVFULPLQDWLRQWRRNSODFHEHFDXVH6SHFLDO $JHQW0DUNRZLF]GRHVQRWDOOHJHWKDWKLVTXDOLILFDWLRQVZHUH³IDUVXSHULRU´WR6SHFLDO$JHQW :\QQ¶VDQGWR6SHFLDO$JHQW1DUDQMR¶V'HI¶V0HPHPSKDVLVRPLWWHG TXRWLQJSingleton v. Potter)6XSSG''& 7KH'HSDUWPHQWFLWHVWRWKHYDOLGSULQFLSOHWKDW WRVKRZWKDWDQHPSOR\HU¶VTXDOLILFDWLRQVEDVHGH[SODQDWLRQIRUKLULQJRUSURPRWLQJVRPHRQH HOVHZDVSUHWH[WXDODSODLQWLIIPXVWVKRZWKDWKH³ZDVµsignificantlyEHWWHUTXDOLILHGIRUWKHMRE¶ WKDQWKRVHXOWLPDWHO\FKRVHQ´Adeyemi v. District of Columbia)G'&&LU

 

  TXRWLQJHolcomb)GDW %XWSURYLQJSUHWH[WLVQRW6SHFLDO$JHQW 0DUNRZLF]¶VEXUGHQDWWKHSOHDGLQJVWDJHZKHQKLVSULQFLSDOEXUGHQLVWRDOOHJHWKDW³VRPHWKLQJ µILVK\¶UDLVHVDQLQIHUHQFHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQ´Mastro)GDWLQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQ PDUNRPLWWHG TXRWLQJHarding)GDW 7KXVDFFHSWLQJDVWUXH6SHFLDO$JHQW 0DUNRZLF]¶VDVVHUWLRQVWKDWKH³KDGPRUHFRPELQHGSURWHFWLRQH[SHULHQFHWKDQWKHRWKHU OLVWHGFDQGLGDWHV´&RPSOˆDQGDFFHSWLQJWKDW6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]ZDVUDQNHGKLJKHU WKDQ6SHFLDO$JHQWV:\QQDQG1DUDQMR&RPSO([WKH&RXUWPXVWFRQFOXGHWKDW6SHFLDO$JHQW 0DUNRZLF]KDVLQGHHGDOOHJHGVRPHWKLQJ³ILVK\´WKDWUDLVHVDQLQIHUHQFHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQ

:LWKUHVSHFWWRWKHDOOHJDWLRQVDERXW$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NR¶VVWDWHPHQWWKH 'HSDUWPHQWDUJXHVWKDWWKH\DUHLUUHOHYDQWWRDQ\DOOHJHGGLVFULPLQDWLRQEHFDXVH³0U/XF]NRLV QRWDOOHJHGWRKDYHEHHQWKHVHOHFWLQJRIILFLDOIRUWKHYDFDQF\WRZKLFK>6SHFLDO$JHQW 0DUNRZLF]@DSSOLHG´'HI¶V0HP%XWWKHFRPSODLQWGRHVDOOHJHWKDW$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU /XF]NRZDVDPHPEHURIWKHSURPRWLRQ$GYLVRU\%RDUGDQGWKHUHIRUHDPHPEHURIWKHERG\ WKDWSURYLGHVWKH6HFUHW6HUYLFH'LUHFWRUZLWKUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVIRUVHOHFWLRQSee&RPSOˆ LQGLFDWLQJWKDWWKH$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRUVDUHDOOPHPEHUVRIWKH$GYLVRU\%RDUG id.ˆˆ DOOHJLQJWKDWWKH%RDUGSURYLGHVWKH6HFUHW6HUYLFH'LUHFWRUZLWKUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVIRU VHOHFWLRQDQGWKDWWKH'LUHFWRUVHOHFWV6SHFLDO$JHQWVIRUSURPRWLRQE\HLWKHUVLJQLQJRUQRW VLJQLQJWKH%RDUG¶VUHFRPPHQGDWLRQOLVW ,QWKHVHFLUFXPVWDQFHVFRXUWVUHJXODUO\WUHDW UHFRPPHQGLQJDQGVHOHFWLQJRIILFLDOVVLPLODUO\DQGDVVXPHWKDWUHFRPPHQGLQJRIILFLDOVZLHOG VLJQLILFDQWGHFLVLRQPDNLQJSRZHUSee, e.g.Carter v. Mineta)$SS¶[± WK&LU Hairsine v. James)6XSSG±±''&  Simpson v. Leavitt)6XSSG±''& Oliver–Simon v. Nicholson )6XSSG±±''& Waters v. Gonzales)6XSSG

 

 ±''& )XUWKHUPRUHEHFDXVHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDUHSDUWRIWKHSURFHVVE\ZKLFK ODWHUVHOHFWLRQVDUHPDGHDQXQIDLURUELDVHGUHFRPPHQGDWLRQFDQUHVXOWLQDQXQIDLUDQGELDVHG VHOHFWLRQCf.Mastro)GDWLQGLFDWLQJWKDWDQ³LQH[SOLFDEO\XQIDLU´LQYHVWLJDWLRQWKDW UHVXOWHGLQWKHSODLQWLII¶VWHUPLQDWLRQZRXOGDOORZDUHDVRQDEOHMXU\WRUHDVRQDEO\FRQFOXGHWKDW GLVFULPLQDWLRQPRWLYDWHGWKHWHUPLQDWLRQ 7KXVEHFDXVH$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NR¶VVWDWHPHQW LISURYHQZRXOGEHHYLGHQFHRIELDVLQWKHUHFRPPHQGLQJSURFHVVWKDWSUHSDUHGWKH6HFUHW 6HUYLFH'LUHFWRU¶VSURPRWLRQVHOHFWLRQVDSURFHVVDERXWZKLFKKHKDGILUVWKDQGNQRZOHGJHWKH VWDWHPHQWLVLQGHHGUHOHYDQWWR6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLP$QGDORQJVLGH WKHTXDOLILFDWLRQVEDVHGDOOHJDWLRQVLWVXIILFHVWRHVWDEOLVKVRPHWKLQJ³ILVK\´KHUHWKDWUDLVHVDQ LQIHUHQFHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQ

)RUWKHVHUHDVRQV6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]KDVDOOHJHGVXIILFLHQW³EDFNJURXQG FLUFXPVWDQFHV´WRVXVWDLQDSULPDIDFLHGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLPDJDLQVWWKH'HSDUWPHQW+HKDVWKXV QHFHVVDULO\DOVR³DOOHJHGIDFWVVXIILFLHQWWRUHQGHUKLVFODLPSODXVLEOHDWWKHPRWLRQWRGLVPLVV VWDJH´Harris)GDW7KH&RXUWWKHUHIRUHUHMHFWVWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VLQYLWDWLRQWRGLVPLVV 6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLP

%$UJXPHQWVIRU6XPPDU\-XGJPHQW

7KH&RXUWWXUQVQRZWRWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VDUJXPHQWVIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWLQLWVIDYRU DQGEHJLQVE\VXPPDUL]LQJWKHUHOHYDQWOHJDOVWDQGDUG

/HJDO6WDQGDUG

8QGHU5XOHRIWKH)HGHUDO5XOHVRI&LYLO3URFHGXUHDFRXUWPXVWJUDQWVXPPDU\ MXGJPHQWLI³WKHPRYDQWVKRZVWKDWWKHUHLVQRJHQXLQHGLVSXWHDVWRDQ\PDWHULDOIDFWDQGWKH PRYDQWLVHQWLWOHGWRMXGJPHQWDVDPDWWHURIODZ´)HG5&LY3D $³PDWHULDO´IDFWLVRQH FDSDEOHRIDIIHFWLQJWKHVXEVWDQWLYHRXWFRPHRIWKHOLWLJDWLRQSeeAnderson v. Liberty Lobby,

 

 Inc.86 $GLVSXWHLV³JHQXLQH´LIWKHUHLVHQRXJKHYLGHQFHIRUD UHDVRQDEOHMXU\WRUHWXUQDYHUGLFWIRUWKHQRQPRYDQWSeeScott v. Harris86  7KHLQTXLU\XQGHU5XOHLVHVVHQWLDOO\³ZKHWKHUWKHHYLGHQFHSUHVHQWVDVXIILFLHQW GLVDJUHHPHQWWRUHTXLUHVXEPLVVLRQWRDMXU\RUZKHWKHULWLVVRRQHVLGHGWKDWRQHSDUW\PXVW SUHYDLODVDPDWWHURIODZ´Anderson86DW±

7KHSULQFLSDOSXUSRVHRIVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWLVWRGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUWKHUHLVDJHQXLQH QHHGIRUWULDOE\GLVSRVLQJRIIDFWXDOO\XQVXSSRUWHGFODLPVRUGHIHQVHVSeeCelotex Corp. v. Catrett86± 7KHPRYDQWEHDUVWKHLQLWLDOEXUGHQRILGHQWLI\LQJ SRUWLRQVRIWKHUHFRUGWKDWGHPRQVWUDWHWKHDEVHQFHRIDQ\JHQXLQHLVVXHRIPDWHULDOIDFWSee )HG5&LY3F  Celotex86DW,QUHVSRQVHWKHQRQPRYDQWPXVWSRLQWWR VSHFLILFIDFWVLQWKHUHFRUGWKDWUHYHDODJHQXLQHLVVXHWKDWLVVXLWDEOHIRUWULDOSee)HG5&LY3 F  Celotex86DW7KHQRQPRYDQWPD\QRWUHVWXSRQPHUHDOOHJDWLRQVRU GHQLDOVEXWPXVWLQVWHDGSUHVHQWDIILUPDWLYHHYLGHQFHLaningham v. U.S. Navy)G '&&LU FLWLQJAnderson86DW 

,QFRQVLGHULQJDPRWLRQIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWDFRXUWPXVW³HVFKHZPDNLQJFUHGLELOLW\ GHWHUPLQDWLRQVRUZHLJKLQJWKHHYLGHQFH´Czekalski v. Peters)G'&&LU  $OOXQGHUO\LQJIDFWVDQGLQIHUHQFHVPXVWEHDQDO\]HGLQWKHOLJKWPRVWIDYRUDEOHWRWKH QRQPRYDQWSeeAnderson86DW1HYHUWKHOHVVFRQFOXVRU\DVVHUWLRQVRIIHUHGZLWKRXW DQ\HYLGHQWLDU\VXSSRUWGRQRWHVWDEOLVKDJHQXLQHLVVXHIRUWULDOSeeGreene v. Dalton)G '&&LU 

*LYHQWKDWWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VPRWLRQIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWFRPHVEHIRUHGLVFRYHU\KDV FRPPHQFHGLQWKLVFDVHWKH&RXUWSD\VVSHFLDOKHHGWRWKHSULQFLSOHWKDWW\SLFDOO\³VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQWPD\QRWEHJUDQWHGXQWLODOOSDUWLHVKDYHKDGDIXOORSSRUWXQLW\WRFRQGXFWGLVFRYHU\´

 

 United States ex rel. Folliard v. Gov’t Acquisitions, Inc.)G'&&LU  LQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQPDUNVRPLWWHG TXRWLQJConvertino v. U.S. Dep’t of Justice)G '&&LU 7KLVSULQFLSOHLVSDUWLFXODUO\UHOHYDQWLQD7LWOH9,,FDVHZKHUH³GLVFRYHU\ PD\HYHQXQFRYHUGLUHFWHYLGHQFHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQWKXVHQWLUHO\HOLPLQDWLQJWKHQHHGWRSURYHD SULPDIDFLHFDVH´Chappell–Johnson v. Powell)G±'&&LU 7KH &RXUWFRXOGWKXVGHQ\WKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VPRWLRQIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWRQ6SHFLDO$JHQW 0DUNRZLF]¶VGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLPVLPSO\EHFDXVHRIWKLVFDVH¶VSUHOLPLQDU\SRVWXUH%XWWR HQVXUHWKDWWKLVFDVHLVQRWWKHDW\SLFDORQHLQZKLFKSUHGLVFRYHU\VXPPDU\MXGJPHQWLVSURSHU WKH&RXUWZLOODQDO\]HWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VDUJXPHQWVRQWKHLUPHULWVCf. Info. Handling Servs., Inc. v. Def. Automated Printing Servs.)G'&&LU H[SODLQLQJWKDW VXPPDU\MXGJPHQW³RUGLQDULO\´LVSURSHURQO\DIWHUGLVFRYHU\LQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQPDUNVRPLWWHG  TXRWLQJAmericable Int’l, Inc. v. Dep’t of Navy)G'&&LU 

$QDO\VLV

7KH'HSDUWPHQW¶VDUJXPHQWVLQIDYRURIVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWUHVWSULQFLSDOO\RQWKHVDPH SRLQWVWKDWLWUDLVHVLQIDYRURIGLVPLVVDOWKHIDFWWKDW6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]GLGQRWKDYH VLJQLILFDQWO\EHWWHUTXDOLILFDWLRQVWKDQWKH6SHFLDO$JHQWVFKRVHQIRUSURPRWLRQDQGWKHLGHDWKDW $VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NR¶VVWDWHPHQWLVLUUHOHYDQWWRWKHGLVFULPLQDWLRQDQDO\VLVSee'HI¶V 0HP±7KHPDLQGLIIHUHQFHLVWKDWRQVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWWKH'HSDUWPHQWFDQUHO\RQLWV RZQHYLGHQFHWRVXSSRUWLWVDUJXPHQWVSee, e.g.id.DW±FLWLQJ6HFUHW6HUYLFHPDQDJHUV¶ GHFODUDWLRQVWRVXSSRUWWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VTXDOLILFDWLRQVEDVHGMXVWLILFDWLRQIRU6SHFLDO$JHQW 0DUNRZLF]¶VQRQSURPRWLRQ id.DWFLWLQJDQH[KLELWWRVKRZWKDW$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NR ³ZDVQRWHYHQSUHVHQWDWWKH$GYLVRU\%RDUGPHHWLQJ´WKDWFRQVLGHUHGWKHSURPRWLRQVWRWKH $76$,&SRVLWLRQVLQWKH3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFHDQG$VVHVVPHQW'LYLVLRQ 

 



%XW6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]DUJXHV²DQGWKH&RXUWDJUHHV²WKDWWKH'HSDUWPHQWGRHV QRWDSSUHFLDWHWKHVLJQLILFDQFHRI$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NR¶VVWDWHPHQWSee3O¶V2SS¶Q± 2QVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWRIFRXUVHWKHQRQPRYDQW¶VHYLGHQFHPXVWEHEHOLHYHGAnderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc.86 DQGVRWKH&RXUWDVVXPHVWKDW$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU /XF]NRGLGPDNHWKHVWDWHPHQW$QGDVGLVFXVVHGHDUOLHUWKHVWDWHPHQWLVUHOHYDQWWRWKH GLVFULPLQDWLRQDQDO\VLVKHUHEHFDXVHHYHQLI$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NRZDVQRWWKHVHOHFWLQJ RIILFLDOKLVVWDWHPHQWLVHYLGHQFHRIELDVLQWKHUHFRPPHQGLQJSURFHVVWKDWSUHSDUHGWKH6HFUHW 6HUYLFH'LUHFWRU¶VHYHQWXDOVHOHFWLRQVSeesupra3DUW,9$FLWLQJMastro v. Potomac Elec. Power Co.)G'&&LU 

)XUWKHUPRUHHYHQLI$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NRZDVQRWKLPVHOISUHVHQWDWWKHPHHWLQJDW ZKLFKWKH$GYLVRU\%RDUGFRQVLGHUHG6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VSURPRWLRQDSSOLFDWLRQWKH UHFRUGLQGLFDWHVWKDWDUHSUHVHQWDWLYHDWWHQGHGRQKLVEHKDOISee'HI¶V0RW([&VKRZLQJWKDW DQRWKHUSHUVRQDWWHQGHGRQEHKDOIRI$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NR¶VRIILFHWKH2IILFHRI 3URIHVVLRQDO5HVSRQVLELOLW\ cf.(OLDV'HFOˆVKRZLQJWKDWZKHQ$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU(OLDV FRXOGQRWDWWHQGDQ$GYLVRU\%RDUGPHHWLQJWKH'HSXW\$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRUIRUKLVRIILFH DWWHQGHGLQKLVVWHDG 7KXVLI$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NRVRXJKWWRXUJHWKH%RDUGWRWDNHUDFLDO FRQVLGHUDWLRQVLQWRDFFRXQWKHFRXOGKDYHGRQHVRWKURXJKKLVUHSUHVHQWDWLYHZLWKRXWEHLQJ 

&XUUHQWO\RQO\6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VUHFROOHFWLRQRI$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NR¶V VWDWHPHQWVXSSRUWVWKHFRQWHQWLRQWKDW$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NRPDGHWKHVWDWHPHQWSee&RPSO ˆ 0DUNRZLF]6HSW'HFOˆ 0DUNRZLF]1RY'HFO3O¶V2SS¶Q([&(&) 1RDW cf./XF]NR'HFOˆˆ±  VWDWLQJWKDW$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NR³GR>HV@QRW UHFDOOPDNLQJWKHµRIIWKHUHFRUGVWDWHPHQW¶DERXWD%ODFNRU+LVSDQLFEHLQJSURPRWHGDKHDGRI >6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]@´

+HDUVD\HYLGHQFHWKDWFDQQRWEHFRQYHUWHGWRDGPLVVLEOHHYLGHQFH LVQRWFRQVLGHUHGRQVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWSeeGreer v. Paulson)G '&&LU 

%XWDVDVWDWHPHQWRIDQRSSRVLQJSDUW\RUWKHRSSRVLQJSDUW\¶VDJHQW$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU /XF]NR¶VVWDWHPHQWOLNHO\LVQRWKHDUVD\See)HG5(YLG G

 '

 VWDWLQJWKDWVWDWHPHQWV DUHQRWKHDUVD\ZKHQ³RIIHUHGDJDLQVWDQRSSRVLQJSDUW\DQGPDGHE\WKHSDUW\¶VDJHQWRU HPSOR\HHRQDPDWWHUZLWKLQWKHVFRSHRIWKDWUHODWLRQVKLSDQGZKLOHLWH[LVWHG´



 

 WKHUHIRUWKH%RDUGPHHWLQJKLPVHOI%XWPRUHLPSRUWDQWO\KLVFRPPHQWVZHUHGLUHFWHGWRKRZ WKHSURFHVVRSHUDWHV²DSURFHVVDERXWZKLFKKHKDGILUVWKDQGNQRZOHGJH²ZKHWKHURUQRWKH ZDVWKHUHRQDQ\SDUWLFXODUGD\7KXVFRQWUDU\WRWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VDUJXPHQWWKDW$VVLVWDQW 'LUHFWRU/XF]NR¶VVWDWHPHQWLV³QRWHYLGHQFHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQGLUHFWRURWKHUZLVH´'HI¶V 5HSO\WKHVWDWHPHQWLVHYLGHQFHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQEHFDXVHLWVXSSRUWVWKHLGHDWKDWWKH%RDUG WRRNUDFLDOFRQVLGHUDWLRQVLQWRDFFRXQW²ZKHWKHUEHFDXVHLWZDVWKH%RDUG¶VVWDQGDUGSUDFWLFHRU EHFDXVH$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NRSURPSWHGWKH%RDUGWRGRVR$QGEHFDXVH$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU /XF]NR¶VVWDWHPHQWUDLVHVDJHQXLQHTXHVWLRQDERXWZKHWKHUUDFLDOFRQVLGHUDWLRQVDIIHFWHGWKH 6HFUHW6HUYLFH¶VGHFLVLRQQRWWRSURPRWH6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]LWUHTXLUHVWKH&RXUWWRGHQ\ WKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VPRWLRQIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWSeeBrady v. Office of the Sergeant at Arms )G'&&LU QRWLQJWKDWHPSOR\HHVPD\HVWDEOLVKWKDWDQHPSOR\HU¶V QRQGLVFULPLQDWRU\UHDVRQIRULWVHPSOR\PHQWDFWLRQZDVSUHWH[WXDO²DQGWKHUHE\DYRLGVXPPDU\ MXGJPHQWDJDLQVWWKHP²ZLWK³HYLGHQFHVXJJHVWLQJWKDWWKHHPSOR\HUWUHDWHGRWKHUHPSOR\HHVRI DGLIIHUHQWUDFHPRUHIDYRUDEO\LQWKHVDPHIDFWXDOFLUFXPVWDQFHV´ 

7KH'HSDUWPHQWGRHVQRWFKDQJHWKH&RXUW¶VFRQFOXVLRQE\FLWLQJWRWKHSULQFLSOHWKDW ³VWUD\UHPDUNVRIQRQGHFLVLRQPDNHUVDUHQRWVXIILFLHQWVWDQGLQJDORQHWRUDLVHDQLQIHUHQFHRI GLVFULPLQDWLRQ´Aliotta v. Bair)GQ'&&LU EUDFNHWVHOOLSVHVDQG LQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQPDUNRPLWWHG TXRWLQJBevan v. Honeywell, Inc.)GWK&LU  see'HI¶V5HSO\±FLWLQJFDVHVLQVXSSRUWRIWKLVSULQFLSOH $VQRWHGHDUOLHU $VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NRSOD\HGDUROHLQWKHGHFLVLRQPDNLQJSURFHVVHYHQLIWKHXOWLPDWH GHFLVLRQGLGQRWUHVWZLWKKLP$QGKLVVWDWHPHQWLVHYLGHQFHQRWMXVWRIKLVRZQSRVVLEOH PRWLYDWLRQWRSURPRWHPLQRULW\DSSOLFDQWVEXWDOVRRIFRQVLGHUDWLRQVDIIHFWLQJWKH$GYLVRU\ %RDUGDVDZKROHSee&RPSOˆUHSRUWLQJWKDW$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NRVWDWHGWKDW³ZH´

  

 PHDQLQJWKH$GYLVRU\%RDUG³KDYHWRSURPRWH´PLQRULW\DSSOLFDQWVLIWKH\DSSHDURQWKHOLVWRI TXDOLILHGDSSOLFDQWV %HFDXVH$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NR¶VVWDWHPHQWVSHDNVWRWKHGHFLVLRQDO SURFHVVXQGHUO\LQJWKHGHFLVLRQQRWWRSURPRWH6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]LWLVHYLGHQFHRI GLVFULPLQDWLRQLQWKHGHFLVLRQDOSURFHVVQRWD³VWUD\UHPDUN´RIDQRQGHFLVLRQPDNHUCf.Spaeth v. Georgetown Univ.)6XSSG''& H[SODLQLQJWKDWXQOLNH$VVLVWDQW 'LUHFWRU/XF]NR¶VVWDWHPHQWKHUH³VWDWHPHQWVE\GHFLVLRQPDNHUVXQUHODWHGWRWKHGHFLVLRQDO SURFHVV´DUHQRWGLUHFWHYLGHQFHLQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQPDUNRPLWWHG TXRWLQJPrice Waterhouse v. Hopkins86 2¶&RQQRU-FRQFXUULQJ 

+DYLQJGHFLGHGWKDWWKH&RXUWPXVWGHQ\WKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VPRWLRQIRUVXPPDU\ MXGJPHQWRQ6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLPEHFDXVHRIWKLVHYLGHQFHWKH &RXUWDGGUHVVHVWKHRWKHUHYLGHQFHLQWKLVFDVHRQO\EULHIO\$VWKH&RXUWIRXQGZKHQDGGUHVVLQJ LWVDUJXPHQWVIRUGLVPLVVDOWKH'HSDUWPHQWFDQQRWILQGUHIXJHLQWKHYDOLGSULQFLSOHWKDWWRVKRZ WKDWDQHPSOR\HU¶VTXDOLILFDWLRQVEDVHGH[SODQDWLRQIRUKLULQJRUSURPRWLQJVRPHRQHHOVHZDV SUHWH[WXDODSODLQWLIIPXVWVKRZWKDWKH³ZDVµsignificantlyEHWWHUTXDOLILHGIRUWKHMRE¶WKDQ WKRVHXOWLPDWHO\FKRVHQ´Adeyemi v. District of Columbia)G'&&LU  TXRWLQJHolcomb v. Powell)G'&&LU see'HI¶V0HP± MXVWLI\LQJ6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VQRQSURPRWLRQE\UHIHUHQFHWRWKLVSULQFLSOH 'HI¶V 5HSO\±VDPH 7KHSUHVHQFHRIWKHDERYHUHIHUHQFHGHYLGHQFHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQKHUHHQWLWOHV 6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]WRSURFHHGWRGLVFRYHU\UHJDUGOHVVRIWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VTXDOLILFDWLRQV EDVHGHYLGHQFHLQLWVIDYRU$QG6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]KDVPRUHHYLGHQFHVXSSRUWLQJKLV HQWLWOHPHQWWRSURFHHGWRGLVFRYHU\

  7KH&RXUWQRWHVKRZHYHUWKDW6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VUDQNLQJZDVVLJQLILFDQWO\ KLJKHUWKDQWKRVHRI6SHFLDO$JHQWV:\QQDQG1DUDQMR

 



7KHUHFRUGDOOXGHVWRRWKHUZD\VLQZKLFK6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]PLJKWDWWDFNWKH 'HSDUWPHQW¶VQRQGLVFULPLQDWRU\MXVWLILFDWLRQVIRUKLVQRQSURPRWLRQ+HLVQRWOLPLWHGWR FRPSDULQJKLVTXDOLILFDWLRQVWRWKRVHRIWKH6SHFLDO$JHQWVWKDWZHUHXOWLPDWHO\SURPRWHGKH FDQDOZD\V³VHHNWRH[SRVHRWKHUIODZVLQWKHHPSOR\HU¶VH[SODQDWLRQ´Hamilton v. Geithner )G'&&LU LQWHUQDOTXRWDWLRQPDUNRPLWWHG TXRWLQJHolcomb )GDW 6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]KDVDOUHDG\GRQHVRLQDQXPEHURIZD\VSee, e.g. 'HI¶V0RW(['ˆ&DWWDFNLQJLQ6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶VDGPLQLVWUDWLYHFRPSODLQW WKHH[SHULHQFHEDVHGMXVWLILFDWLRQVIRUVHOHFWLQJ6SHFLDO$JHQWV:\QQDQG1DUDQMRRYHU6SHFLDO $JHQW0DUNRZLF] 0DUNRZLF]6HSW'HFOˆVDPHLQDODWHUGHFODUDWLRQ 0DUNRZLF] 1RY'HFO(&)1RDW±VDPH $PRQJRWKHUWKLQJVKHKLJKOLJKWVWKHIDFW WKDW6SHFLDO$JHQW(GZDUGVZDVSURPRWHG³GHVSLWHKDYLQJQHLWKHU3UHVLGHQWLDO3URWHFWLYH 'LYLVLRQH[SHULHQFHQRU3URWHFWLYH,QWHOOLJHQFH>DQG$VVHVVPHQW@'LYLVLRQH[SHULHQFHEXW KDYLQJ9LFH3UHVLGHQWLDO3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQH[SHULHQFH´OLNH6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF] 0DUNRZLF]6HSW'HFOˆaccord0DUNRZLF]1RY'HFO(&)1RDW± $QGKHQRWHVWKDWHYHQLI6SHFLDO$JHQW:\QQ¶V3UHVLGHQWLDO3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQH[SHULHQFH PDGHKLPEHWWHUTXDOLILHGIRUSURPRWLRQIRXURWKHUZKLWH6SHFLDO$JHQWVZLWK3UHVLGHQWLDO 3URWHFWLYH'LYLVLRQH[SHULHQFHZHUHQRWSURPRWHGGHVSLWHEHLQJUDQNHGKLJKHUWKDQ6SHFLDO $JHQW:\QQSee0DUNRZLF]6HSW'HFOˆ0DUNRZLF]1RY'HFO(&)1R DW

$QG6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]KDVDOOXGHGWR\HWDQRWKHUVRXUFHRIFLUFXPVWDQWLDO HYLGHQFHWRUHEXWWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VQRQGLVFULPLQDWRU\H[SODQDWLRQIRUKLVQRQSURPRWLRQ

  %HFDXVH6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]¶V1RYHPEHUGHFODUDWLRQODFNVLQWHUQDOSDJH QXPEHUVWKH&RXUWFLWHVWRWKHSDJHQXPEHUVDXWRPDWLFDOO\JHQHUDWHGE\(&)

 

 HYLGHQFHRIDSDWWHUQRUSUDFWLFHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQZKLFKFDQEHFROODWHUDOHYLGHQFHWRVXSSRUWDQ LQGLYLGXDO¶VGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLPSeeArtis v. Yellen)5'''& QRWLQJ WKDW³SDWWHUQRUSUDFWLFH´HYLGHQFHFDQEROVWHUDQLQGLYLGXDO¶VGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLP see also Holcomb)GDWH[SODLQLQJWKDWD7LWOH9,,SODLQWLIIFDQFKDOOHQJHDQHPSOR\HU¶V OHJLWLPDWHQRQGLVFULPLQDWRU\H[SODQDWLRQZLWK³GDWDVKRZLQJWKDWWKHGHIHQGDQWHPSOR\V>RU SURPRWHV@PHPEHUVRIWKHSODLQWLII¶VSURWHFWHGFODVVDWUDWHVIDUEHORZWKHLUQXPEHUVLQWKH DSSOLFDQWSRRODQGWKHJHQHUDOSRSXODWLRQ´ $ORQJWKHVHOLQHV6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]KDV QRWHGWKDWRQWZRRWKHURFFDVLRQVLQWKH6HFUHW6HUYLFHFKRVHDORZHUUDQNHGPLQRULW\ DSSOLFDQWIRUSURPRWLRQLQVWHDGRIDKLJKHUUDQNHGZKLWHPDOHDSSOLFDQWSee0DUNRZLF]6HSW 'HFOˆ,IDIWHUGLVFRYHU\6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]FDQHVWDEOLVKWKDWWKLVSDWWHUQLV VWDWLVWLFDOO\VLJQLILFDQWWKHQWKLVHYLGHQFH²WRJHWKHUZLWKKLVRWKHUHYLGHQFHRIGLVFULPLQDWLRQ DQGWKHDOOHJHGIODZVLQWKH6HFUHW6HUYLFH¶VTXDOLILFDWLRQVEDVHGMXVWLILFDWLRQVIRUKLV QRQSURPRWLRQ²FRXOGSRWHQWLDOO\UDLVHDJHQXLQHLVVXHRIPDWHULDOIDFWDERXWZKHWKHUUDFLDO FRQVLGHUDWLRQVPRWLYDWHGWKH6HFUHW6HUYLFH¶VGHFLVLRQQRWWRSURPRWHKLPSee generallyBolden v. Clinton)6XSSG''& H[SODLQLQJWKDWDSODLQWLIIPXVW³HVWDEOLVKWKH VWDWLVWLFDOVLJQLILFDQFHRIKLV>SDWWHUQRUSUDFWLFH@HYLGHQFH´IRULWWREHSUREDWLYHRI

GLVFULPLQDWLRQ



6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]KDVWKXVUDLVHGVHYHUDOVRXUFHVRIFLUFXPVWDQWLDOHYLGHQFH²LQ DGGLWLRQWR$VVLVWDQW'LUHFWRU/XF]NR¶VVWDWHPHQW²WKDWHQWLWOHKLPWRH[SORUHLQGLVFRYHU\WKH 6HFUHW6HUYLFH¶VPRWLYDWLRQVZKHQLWFKRVHQRWWRSURPRWHKLP7KHTXHVWLRQVWKDW6SHFLDO$JHQW 0DUNRZLF]KDVUDLVHGUHTXLUHWKH&RXUWWRDWOHDVWIRUQRZGHQ\WKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VPRWLRQIRU VXPPDU\MXGJPHQW

 



9&21&/86,21

%HFDXVH6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]KDVZLWKGUDZQKLVUHWDOLDWLRQFODLPWKH&RXUWZLOO GLVPLVVWKDWFODLP%HFDXVH6SHFLDO$JHQW0DUNRZLF]KDVVWDWHGDSODXVLEOHGLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLP DQGEHFDXVHJHQXLQHLVVXHVH[LVWPHULWLQJGLVFRYHU\ZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKDWFODLPWKH&RXUWGHQLHV WKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VPRWLRQWRGLVPLVVRULQWKHDOWHUQDWLYHIRUVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWRQWKH GLVFULPLQDWLRQFODLP

)RUWKHIRUHJRLQJUHDVRQVWKH'HSDUWPHQW¶VPRWLRQWRGLVPLVVRULQWKHDOWHUQDWLYHIRU VXPPDU\MXGJPHQW(&)1R LV*5$17(',13$57DQG'(1,(',13$57$QRUGHU FRQVLVWHQWZLWKWKLV0HPRUDQGXP2SLQLRQLVVHSDUDWHO\DQGFRQWHPSRUDQHRXVO\LVVXHG

'DWHG 6HSWHPEHU 58'2/3+&2175(5$6  8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW-XGJH