Full text
Owner-Operator Independent Dri v. Eric Holcomb
In the
United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit
PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPT
'ET:8Q9<<=T QT T T FT EF- #- EFT #", #"FT
%)T
T FT'. *&'*T' T & !&F-#- EFT #", "ET
PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPT
(( $T *'%T, T&!, T,, +T!+,*!,T'-*,T '*T, T '-, *&T!+,*!,T' T & !&FT & !&('$!+T!.!+!'&ET 'ET9G9AQ.Q888@>Q Q TST F- $ET
PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPT
TT:>FT:8:8TST T TAFT:8:9T
PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPT
'* T FTFT& TF-!$#- $"ET F- !$#- $ET T & !&T '$$T ' FT (*,T ' T QA8FT*-&+T9=>T%!$ +T*'++T&'*, *&T & !&T *'%T, T'*Q *T /!, T !'T '&T , T +,T ,'T , T ! 'T #1/1T '&T , T / +,ET /& T 1T , T & !&T !&& T -, '*!,1FT , T '$$T ' T +T &T'( *, T+!& T:88>T1TT$ ++ FT T'& +Q +!'&T '%(&1ET ,T T &T * T ( & +T '&T +,, T $/FT & T !&T :89@T T (! T , T +,, T C9T !$$!'&T !&T 0 & T '*T
:T 'ET:8Q9<<=T
( *%!++!'&T ,'T *!+ T 1T ;=BT , T ,'$$+T '&T .1T ,*-#+T J, '+ T /!, T , * T '*T %'* T 0$ +KET &T , !+T +-!,FT ( *+'&+T & T &,!,! +T , ,T '/&T & T '( *, T .1T ,*-#+T '&, & T , ,T , T ,'$$T !&Q * + T.!'$, +T, T'%% * T$-+ T' T, T'&+,!,-,!'&T1T $$!& T (*!&!($$1T '&T !&, *+,, T ,*6ET $!&,!5+T $$ T , ,T =8BT ' T , T .1T ,*-#+T , ,T -+ T , T '$$T ' T ,*&+!,T , T +,, T & T , ,T A8BT ' T .1Q,*-#T ,*6T *'++ +T , T +,, M+T '* *+T,T'& T,!% T'*T&', *ET! *T,'$$+T'&T, + T,*-#+T , * '* T !+*!%!&, T !&+,T!&, *+,, T'%% * FT($!&,!5+T %!&,!&ET 1T T , ,T , T ,'$$+T * T -&"-+,!3 T -+ T &'& T ' T , T C9T !$$!'&T /!$$T T -+ T ,'T %!&,!&T '*T !%(*'. T , T'$$T' ETJ & !&T &! +T+'% T' T, + T$$ ,!'&+FT-,T / T++-% T '*T-** &,T(-*('+ +T, ,T($!&,!5+T* T'** ,EKT T % !+,*, T "- T * '%% & T , ,T , T +-!,T T !+Q %!++ T'&T, T *'-& T, ,T & !&FT+TT%*# ,T(*,!!(&,FT !+T 0 %(,T *'%T , T *-$ +T '* !&*!$1T (($! T , *'- T '%Q % * T "-*!+(*- & ET :89AT EET !+,ET T ::@A=@T JEET & ET - ET 9:FT :89AKET T !+,*!,T "- T * T & T !+%!++ T , T +-!,T-& *T ETET!.ETET9:JKJ>KT '*T !$-* T,'T+,, TT$!%T '&T / ! T * $! T %1T T *&, ET :8:8T EET !+,ET T <99;@T JEET & ET *ET98FT:8:8KET $"- %)- ' !- ! - ! EFT <:>T EET ?A<T J9A?>KFT '$ +T , ,FT / &T T +,, T (*,!!(, +T !&S*, *T , &T * -Q $, +S, T%*# ,FT!,T!+T &,!,$ T,'T !+*!%!&, T!&T .'*T' T!,+T '/&T!,!2 &+E-$"T+-+,!& TT'-&,1T, ,T *1$& T(! T !,+T'/&T!,!2 &+T '*T, T !+('+$T' T"-&#T*+ET , *T !+!'&+FT +- T +T %"*- )- %)- #FT <<?T EET <:AT J9A@8KFT * " ,T $Q $ & +T,'T 0$-+!'&+T+T/ $$T+T+-+! ! +ET &T%"T'-, TQ #',T $!%!, T +$ +T *'%T T +,, Q'/& T % &,T ($&,T ,'T !,!Q 2 &+T ' T '-, T #',ET &T , + T & T %&1T +- ++'*T !Q +!'&+FT, T -+,! +T . T'&3& T&$1+!+T-& *T, T '*%&,T
'ET:8Q9<<=T ;T
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
<T 'ET:8Q9<<=T
*&% &,T *'# T !&,'T , T ,*&+('*,,!'&T -+!& ++FT !,T /+T +T T (*'.! *T' T$& T '*T(*!., T*!$*' +FT&',T+TT-!$ *T'*T'(Q *,'*ET& T . &T !&T :8:9T * )- &,$1T -+ T . &- +T ' T ,*&+Q ('*,,!'&S'!$T& T +T(!( $!& +FT $ ,*!$T !+,*!-,!'&T *! +FT &$+FT +'% T !*('*,+FT +'% T *! +FT %&1T **! +FT %&1T ('*,+T& T *'*+FT%&1T*!$*' +S* %!&T!&T(*!., T & +ET T! T, ,T,*&+('*,,!'&T& ++*!$1T!+TT+,, T -&,!'&T!+T -&, &$ ET -+,T +#T , T . $'( *+T ' T * +! &,!$T +- !.!Q +!'&+FT& T, T'/& *+T' T *%+FT/ ! T* T 0( , T,'T-!$ T & T%!&,!&T, !*T'/&T*' +ET T %1T +-(('+ FT +T ($!&,!5+T $$ FT , ,T , T C9T !$$!'&T * !. T '*T, T:89@T,'$$T!&* + T/+T-+ T '*T+,, T(-*('+Q +T -&* $, T ,'T %!&, && T ' T , T '$$T ' ET 1T + '-$ T , ,T %7 *ITT +,, FT $!# T &1T (*!., T (*'(*! ,'*FT &T ,-*&T T (*'3,T *'%T!,+T,!.!,! +ET$!&,!5+T('!&,T'-,T, ,T!&-% "% , !$!- ! !#- $# !#(- %)- #- ! "*- )FT <8=T EET ?8?T J9A?:KFT / ! T $ T , ,T T ( *Q(++ & *T ,0T ,T T +,, Q '/& T !*('*,T ! T &',T .!'$, T , T '*%&,T '%% * T $-+ FT , T '-*,T '+ *. FT %'& T ', *T , !& +FT , ,T , T %'& 1T/+T-+ T,'T%!&,!&T, T!*('*,ET% "% T(* +T , T3*+,T%*# ,Q(*,!!(&,T+ FT '/ . *FT& T . &T+'T ' +T &',T +1T , ,T , T .$! !,1T ' T , T T ( & T '&T '/T , T %'& 1T /+T -+ ET T '-*,T $+'T '+ *. T , ,T , T T /+T &'& !+*!%!&,'*1T& T ! T&',T'&4!,T/!, T&1T *$T('$Q !1ET '+ T, !& +T* T )-$$1T,*- T' T & !&M+T,'$$+ET T'&Q +,!,-,!'&T ' +T&',T +,$!+ T, T *$T"- !!*1T+TT* -$Q ,'*1T '%%!++!'&FT , *T , T + !'&T ' T -,!$!,1T *, T * -$,'*+T , ,T ,*1T ,'T # (T &,-*$T %'&'('$! +MT * +T !&T $!& T /!, T '&+-% *+MT & 3,+ET *-# *+T / 'T /&,T ,'T .'! T , T ,'$$+T &T -+ T , T %&1T * T *' +T !&T & !&T J!&$- !& T ,/'T ,'$$Q * T !&, *+,, T ! /1+T , ,T *'++T , T %! $ T & T +'-, T ' T , T+,, T *'%T +,T,'T/ +,KET
'ET:8Q9<<=T =T
T . T+! T &'- T,'T+ '/T, ,T, T,'$$T!&* + T!+T.$Q ! T . &T ! T ,* , T +T !+*!%!&,!& T !&+,T !&, *+,, T '%Q % * ET T& T,'T T$ *T'&T, !+T('!&,GT/ T . -++-% T '*T, T+# T' T* -% &,T, ,T, * T/'-$ T TT'&+,!,-,!'&$T (*'$ %T! T & !&T/ * TT* -$,'*T*, *T, &TT(*'(*! ,'*FT -,T / T 'T &',T +'T '$ ET T ,'$$+T * T & -,*$T /!, T * +( ,T ,'T , T '*! !&T & T +,!&,!'&T ' T , T ,*-#+ET 1T * T & -,*$T /!, T * +( ,T ,'T ,*-#+MT '/& *+ !(T ,''ET !,!2 &+T ' T & !&T / 'T-+ T, T'$$T' T,'T -$T * ! ,T *'%T$# *,T,'T*1T (1T , T +% T *, T ( *T %!$ FT ( *T 0$ FT +T 'T !,!2 &+T ' T !+Q '&+!&T / 'T -$T * ! ,T *'%T !'T , *'- T & !&T ,'T $$!Q &'!+T& T 1'& ET !+!'&+T +- T +T ! - !$ - "" # "*- )- %)- !FT <@;T EET :>>T J9A@?KFT / ! T ,* ,T 4,T ,*&+('*,,!'&T ,0 +T +T !+*!%!&,'*1FT 'T &',T 5 ,T , T .$! !,1T ' T T ( *Q %!$ T ,'$$ET T ('!&,T ' - ! - !$ T /+T , ,T T 4,T ,0T J+1FTC=88T( *T,*-#T( *T1 *KT/'-$ T $$T%'* T .!$1T'&T, T '/& *T ' T T ,*-#T , ,T (++ T , *'- T &&+1$.&!T '& T T 1 *T, &T'&T, T!&Q+,, T'/& *T' TT,*-#T, ,T% T$'$T Q $!. *! +T !&T !7+-* ET T '-,Q' Q+,, T '/& *T %! ,T & T -(T (1!& TC=T( *T%!$ TJ& T%&1T, '-+& +T' T '$$*+T! T', *T +,, +T T, T+% T+ % KFT/ !$ T, T!&Q+,, T'/& *T/'-$ T (1T'&$1T( &&! +T( *T%!$ ETT( *Q%!$ T,'$$FT1T'&,*+,FT,* ,+T . *1'& T $!# ET &T , !+T * +( ,T T ( *Q%!$ T ,'$$T !+T &'T !5 * &,T *'%T T ,0T '&T +'$!& T '*T ! + $T - $FT '*T , ,T ,0T !+T (! T !&T (*'('*,!'&T,'T-+ ET T -(* % T '-*,T %! ,T / $$T %T , T + & T ' T 0Q (* ++T !+*!%!&,!'&T '&$-+!. T !&T .'*T ' T T ( *Q%!$ T ,'$$ET T * ' &!2 T , ,- - %)- !$- $!*- )FT ;A?T EET 9;?T J9A?8KFT * )-!* +T ,T $ +,T +'% T 0,*T "-+,!3,!'&T J 1'& T , T +,& * T *,!'&$Q+!+T , +,KT '*T +'% T * -$,!'&+T , ,T *T
>T 'ET:8Q9<<=T
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