Williams v. Shaw

Peabody, J. —Plaintiff is not bound to furnish particulars of set-offs or payments by defendant, with which he volunteers to credit him in his complaint. As to particulars of plaintiff’s claim, he swears he has given them as fully as he can, and all he has of them; and though they are somewhat vague, perhaps nothing more can be required of him. The motion for further particulars, in both its branches, must be denied; but without costs.