Chapman v. Palmer

Harris, Justice. I have no hesitation in pronouncing this-answer evasive and frivolous. The allegation in the complaint is, that the plaintiff, at different times during the present .year, sold and delivered to the defendants, as partners, certain goods. Whether or not this allegation is true, the defendants may be reasonably supposed to know. One of them, by his failure- to answer, admits that it.is true. The other says, that for the want of any knowledge or information on the subject, he is unable to say whether- it is true or not. As the answer is verified by the oath of the defendant, we are, perhaps, required to believe that this is so. But if it be really so, the defendant’s ignorance is quite unnecessary. Intentional ignorance is not such as the legislature had in view, when it authorized a defendant to put in issue any allegation of a complaint when he had no knowledge or information as to its truth, by stating such ignorance. The defendant who has answered, if he did not in fact know whether his partner or his clerks had purchased the goods of the plaintiff, as alleged, was bound, before answering, to- inform himself on the. subject. This he could have done by simple inquiry. If he has omitted such inquiry, he is wilfully ignorant of what it was his duty to know. If there was anything to prevent his informing himself, as to the facts alleged in the complaint, he should have stated what it was, by'way of excusing himself for this mode of answering. In the absence of any such excuse, he must, as one of the partners, to whom the goods are alleged to have been sold, be held to be chargeable with such knowl 39 edge or information on the subject, as would enable him to admit or deny the allegation. The answer, that he has no such knowledge or information, must be regarded as an evasion. (See Edwards agt. Lent, 8 How. 28; Richardson agt. Wilton, 4 Sand. 708; Wesson agt. Judd, 1 Abbott, 254; Thorn agt. N.Y. Central Mills, 10 How. 19; Shearman agt. N. Y. Central Mills, 1 Abbott, 187.) The motion must be granted, with costs.