Full text
Robert Bosch LLC v. Pylon Mfg. Corp.

Loading…
Opinion
659 F.3d 1142 · Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit · Nov 4, 2011
Full text
Robert Bosch LLC v. Pylon Mfg. Corp.
E.D. Michigan · Aug 8, 2025
E.D. California · Jun 13, 2025
M.D. Florida · May 29, 2025
N.D. Illinois · May 27, 2025
D. Massachusetts · Apr 24, 2025
E.D. Texas · Dec 4, 2024
Parentheticals
holding that, in the context of patent infringement cases, there is no presumption of irreparable harm when a party estab- lishes liability for patent infringement
reasoning that “the likely availability of those monetary payments helps define the circumstances” of whether a party is irreparably harmed absent an injunction
noting "eBay abolishes our general rule that an injunction normally will issue when a patent is found to have been valid and infringed"
confirming “that eBay jettisoned the presumption of irreparable harm as it applies to determining the appropriateness of injunctive relief”
finding it was 17 error for the district court to fail to consider whether the defendant would be able to pay a 18 monetary award as a viable alternative to an injunction
“A party cannot escape an injunction simply because it is smaller than the patentee or because its primary product is an infringing one.”
FenF, LLC v. Zhanjiang Yongxiao Information Consulting Studio
“A party cannot escape an injunction simply because it is smaller than the patentee or because its primary product is an infringing one.”
“While competitive harms theoretically can be offset by monetary payments in certain circumstances, the likely availability of those monetary payments helps define the circumstances in which this is so.”
“We take this opportunity to put the question to rest and confirm that eBay jettisoned the presumption of irreparable harm as it applies to determining the appropriateness of injunctive relief.”
“We take this opportunity to put the question to rest and confirm that eBay jettisoned the presumption of irreparable harm as it applies to determining the appropriateness of injunctive relief.”
“We take this opportunity to put the question to rest and confirm that eBay jettisoned the presumption of irreparable harm as it applies to determining the appropriateness of injunctive relief.”