Full text
Richard S. Hartshorne and Holmes Van Mater ads. Peter Johnson, John Van Pelt, and Matthias Van Brackle
Per Curiam.
We are of opinion that there must be a new trial. -'The defendants had a right to retain in their hands sufficient to pay -themselves for the transportation of the one hundred and thirty-four barrels, but for no inore. The possession, as to this, was never given up, or the lien destroyed. As to the validity of the judgment in attachment, we think we cannot look into it in this collateral way. We do not, however, consider this as coming in question here.
New trial granted.